I am trying to decide whether to stay with The Bat (moving back to the last version 1 
version which I guess is 1.62) or whether to simply move to another email program. I 
find staying with Version 2 impossible because there are several mailing lists that I 
post to where some of my messages end up in Base 64 encoding. To make a long story 
short, I have checked all of my TB setting including the quotable-printable thing and 
I still have the problem even though I am now totally posting using plain text, fixed 
width font, etc. I am convinced that this is not something that I am doing. Rather it 
is something about how TB itself is working in version 2 that seems to cause this 
problem for some subset of users. I never know when the problem will occur. It is on 
some replies but occasionally even on new messages. I am persuaded that this is 
something only the developers can fix and since it is a low incidence problem 
(although seemingly persistent for a few of us) am doubtful it will be solved.

�

So, I must look at alternatives. The decision is whether to step back to the lower 
version of TB or whether to go with another program. The difficulty I am having is 
that I know what features I really like about TB (and which I don't), but I no longer 
know which programs have those features and which are unique to TB. I know that many 
on this list do keep other with other mail program so would appreciate input so I can 
figure out which program has the best total mix of needed features:

�

Programs I have looked at so far to a greater or lesser extent:

�

TB, version 1.62 -- used this one before version 2

Becky -- My impression is filtering is limited

Pocomail -- Like the interface a lot

Pegasus -- Don't like the interface

Eudora -- What I used to use up through version 4.2 and then changed to TB. Downloaded 
current but haven't tried yet.

Mahogany -- Suggested to me but not tried yet.

�

What is important to me:

�

1. Must be able to do a filter that does two things or run multiple filters to do the 
following: I move list mail to a folder for that list. Simultaneously, I want a copy 
of the message to be moved to another folder, and marked read, so that I can then 
maintain a complete archive of all list mails. Pocomail and Pegasus seem to be able to 
do this. Don't know about Eudora. Doesn't seem like Becky could do it. What can TB do 
on filters that no other program can do? Which program has filter abilities most 
similar to that of TB?

�

2. Must be able to handle keeping around a lot of messages. I have complete archives 
of mailing lists going back a few years. This is a couple of hundred thousand 
messages. TB can handle this. Is this unique to TB or can others?

�

3. I like to be able to compose and view messages using whatever font is comfortable 
for me. With TB version 2, I am currently limited to basically having to look at 
Courier all the time. Virtually all other mail programs seem superior to TB in this 
regard.

�

4. While I don't send messages in HTML, I like being able to easily read HTML 
messages. TB seems more limited than programs such as Pocomail and Pegasus.

�

5. Quick templates. I have several quick templates I like to use in TB. Is this type 
of thing unique to TB or do other programs have similar functionality?

�

6. Multiple signatures that you can automatically set up to be used with different 
types of messages (that is, filter A to all messages to List B and Filter C for all 
messages to List D). Do other programs now have this ability?

�

7. A minor point -- but one dear to my heart. On TB, I have a cookies file that 
randomly inserts selected quotes as a tagline. What other programs can do this? I 
think Pegasus can, but I hate its interface so much that probably isn't enough to make 
me go with Pegasus. Can Pocomail or Eudora or any other program do this other than TB?

�

8. Easy ability to search and find specific messages. Eudora, way back when, was very 
good with this. TB below version 2 was weak in this area. TB, version 2 is much better 
and this is one reason I hate to have to go back a version. Pocomail seems to work 
well in this regard, don't know about others.

�

So, which programs have these features? Of those programs are there major negatives or 
bugs that weigh against these features. Looking at my archive I saw someone posted a 
negative comment about Pocomail and serious bug about 6 months ago. However, I don't 
know what the negatives are other than I've heard it is "slow" but it hasn't been slow 
for me the past couple of days.



________________________________________________
Current version is 2.01.3 | "Using TBUDL" information:
http://www.silverstones.com/thebat/TBUDLInfo.html

Reply via email to