TidBITS#872/26-Mar-07
=====================
Issue link: <http://db.tidbits.com/issue/872>
This week we're featuring audio and video, music and TV. First, Adam
reviews SpotDJ, a new Web-enabled service that puts the DJ back into
iTunes with short audio spots that you hear after appropriate songs
play in iTunes or on your iPod. Then, Jeff offers his initial
impressions of the just-shipped Apple TV after a popcorn-fueled
"testing" session. But we didn't spend the entire week goofing off,
as Glenn looks at Other World Computing's 3 GB memory kit to max out
the RAM on certain Macs along with how it might impact performance.
Adam also examines Chax, a free utility that gives iChat a tabbed
interface and a plethora of useful configuration options. In the
news, we cover the release of SpamSieve 2.6 and how to get MacTech's
VBA-to-AppleScript transition guide for Microsoft Office users.
Articles
SpamSieve 2.6 Adds Thunderbird Support
MacTech 25 Voting Open, VBA to AppleScript Guide Available
DealBITS Drawing: BeLight Software's Art Text
Enhance iChat with Chax
Stick 3 GB of RAM in an Intel Core 2 Duo iMac, MacBook
Add a DJ to iTunes with SpotDJ
Apple TV: The Real Video iPod
Hot Topics in TidBITS Talk/26-Mar-07
------------ This issue of TidBITS sponsored in part by: --------------
* READERS LIKE YOU! Support TidBITS with a contribution today!
<http://www.tidbits.com/about/support/contributors.html>
Special thanks this week to Pamela Tobey, Bryan Simcock,
Allen Carter, and John Busteed for their generous support!
* SMALL DOG ELECTRONICS: TidBITS Exclusive for Mar 26-Apr 2:
17" PowerBook G4, 1.67 GHz, 120 GB hard drive, SuperDrive,
AP/BT, Tiger + Classic, Apple refurbished, one-year warranty
Free shipping, $1389! Order at <http://www.smalldog.com/tb/>
* GET FETCH 5 FOR FREE! Fetch Softworks makes Fetch, the original
Macintosh FTP client, free for educational and charitable use.
Fetch 5.2 includes WebView, FTPS, and droplet shortcuts.
Apply today at <http://fetchsoftworks.com/edapply>!
* WebCrossing Neighbors Creates Private Social Networks
Create a complete social network with your company or group's
own look. Scalable, extensible and extremely customizable.
Take a guided tour today <http://www.webcrossing.com/tour>
* MARK/SPACE, INC: New, from the makers of The Missing Sync, comes
SyncTogether, a brand new app for syncing contacts, calendars,
notes and more between multiple Macs and one or more user
accounts. $49.95 for 3 Macs. <http://www.markspace.com/bits>
* CheckIt System Performance Suite bundles three top Mac utilities!
TechTool Platinum diagnoses and repairs your disk, Spring Cleaning
organizes your files and Retrospect Express backs up your data.
Buy today for only $79.99! <http://www.allume.com/tidbits/>
* Microsoft's MacBU: Supporting Mac users with Office 2004.
Supporting the Mac community through tech support newsgroups,
user group appearances, our new team blog, and more!
Check out our team blog at <http://blogs.msdn.com/macmojo/>
* DealBITS: Get the word out about your product AND generate sales!
It's easy: give away a few copies and offer a discount to entrants.
A DealBITS drawing is quick to set up and can easily pay for itself.
For more info and rates, visit <http://www.tidbits.com/dealbits/>.
---------- Help support TidBITS by supporting our sponsors ------------
SpamSieve 2.6 Adds Thunderbird Support
--------------------------------------
by Adam C. Engst <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
article link: <http://db.tidbits.com/article/8920>
Michael Tsai has released SpamSieve 2.6, a notable update to his
popular spam-filtering tool. This version adds Mozilla Thunderbird
to the extensive list of supported email programs and improves
detection of image spam and phishing messages. Both are tricky to
identify, the former due to either a complete lack of text or to a
great deal of random text along with the image payload, and the
latter because the text so closely mimics normal messages. Other
improvements include more efficient AppleScript support, improved
compatibility with pre-release versions of Mac OS X 10.5 Leopard,
and a variety of minor tweaks to the Apple Mail plug-in. SpamSieve
2.6 is a free upgrade for registered users; new copies cost $30 and
there's a 30-day trial version. The program requires any version of
Mac OS X after 10.2.8, with 10.4 or later recommended.
<http://c-command.com/spamsieve/>
<http://c-command.com/blog/2007/03/19/spamsieve-26/>
MacTech 25 Voting Open, VBA to AppleScript Guide Available
----------------------------------------------------------
by Adam C. Engst <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
article link: <http://db.tidbits.com/article/8926>
MacTech Magazine is once again accepting votes for the 2007 MacTech
25, a roundup of the people who contribute the most technical
assistance to the Macintosh community through their writing,
speaking, and problem-solving. MacTech internal staff aren't
eligible and Apple employees will be included only on an honorable
mention list, so please, cast your votes for the people who provide
you with the most useful technical information.
<http://www.mactech.com/mostinfluential/>
Last year, Tonya and I made the list because of our work on TidBITS
and Take Control, but please let me encourage you also to vote for
our colleagues, since Matt Neuburg has done great work in the
AppleScript world, Glenn Fleishman is the preeminent journalist
covering wireless networking, Joe Kissell has written our
top-selling Take Control ebooks, and Jeff Carlson is well known for
his books on video and Palm OS handhelds.
<http://www.mactech.com/articles/mactech/Vol.22/22.08/2006MacTech25/>
Also, if you don't currently receive MacTech and are interested in
scripting Microsoft Office, you might wish to consider subscribing.
For only $10 shipping and handling plus some answers to survey
questions, you can receive six months of MacTech along with the
150-page "Moving from Microsoft Office VBA to AppleScript: MacTech's
Guide to Making the Transition." The next version of Microsoft
Office for the Mac won't support Visual Basic for Applications
(VBA), Microsoft's own scripting environment, and will instead rely
on AppleScript, a move which will require changes in Office-based
automation. The offer is good through 01-Apr-07.
<http://www.mactech.com/ms-survey/vba-applescript.php>
DealBITS Drawing: BeLight Software's Art Text
---------------------------------------------
by Adam C. Engst <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
article link: <http://db.tidbits.com/article/8918>
As a non-artist, I'm always a sucker for programs that let me create
interesting graphical effects - especially with text - without
requiring Photoshop. So BeLight Software's new Art Text is a
dangerous program for me to launch, since I can waste way too much
time playing with its many built-in and user-configurable options
for turning text and simple vector graphics into cool logotypes. A
few minutes of fiddling with various options produced this graphic
of the word "TidBITS" in the Ransom font, along with an arrow
dingbat pointing at a penguin, each in different styles. In the
just-released Art Text 1.2, BeLight added new transformation types
for squeezing text into particular shapes, additional shading
materials, many new pictograms, and a set of styles for Web 2.0-like
graphics, making it easy to generate those ray-traced logotypes that
have become so popular on hip new Web sites. Personally, I like
playing with the variables that control the color, light direction,
depth, shadow, and glow, and Art Text can even import existing
images as backgrounds, textures, or materials. Art Text requires Mac
OS X 10.4 or later, and there's a free demo available as an 8 MB
download; be sure to watch BeLight's screencast for a good overview
of Art Text's features.
<http://www.belightsoft.com/products/arttext/overview.php>
<http://www.tidbits.com/resources/2007-03/TidBITS-penguin.jpg>
<http://www.belightsoft.com/productfiles/BS001-Art_Text_960x540.mov>
In this week's DealBITS drawing, you can enter to win one of four
copies of Art Text 1.2, each worth $29.95. Entrants who aren't among
our lucky winners will receive a discount on Art Text, so be sure to
enter at the DealBITS page linked below. All information gathered is
covered by our comprehensive privacy policy. Be careful with your
spam filters and challenge-response systems, since you must be able
to receive email from my address to learn if you've won. Remember
too, that if someone you refer to this drawing wins, you'll receive
the same prize as a reward for spreading the word.
<http://www.tidbits.com/dealbits/art-text/>
<http://www.tidbits.com/about/privacy.html>
Enhance iChat with Chax
-----------------------
by Adam C. Engst <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
article link: <http://db.tidbits.com/article/8921>
iChat has increasingly become a necessary aspect of business and
personal communication, but I still don't love the program. I remain
peeved by its approach to status (see "iChat Status Report,"
2004-03-29) and its general clumsiness. Oddly for an Apple program,
iChat uses lots of individual windows, and since you often want to
switch among them, having them in separate windows in the
window-layered Mac OS X (as opposed to the way Mac OS 9 was by
default application-layered) can require some additional fussing.
<http://db.tidbits.com/article/7606>
A while back, I was turned on to Kent Sutherland's Chax, a free
(donations gladly accepted) utility that extends and enhances iChat
in numerous ways. It installs directly into iChat, so you can set
its preferences in a tab of the normal iChat preferences window.
I've seen no instability or odd behavior because of it, and as such
I'd encourage anyone bothered by iChat to check it out. It is an
Input Manager that injects itself into every application, which is
entirely appropriate behavior, but if you install Chax and find that
you're not using it, you can uninstall it as explained on its Web
site. (For more information about Input Managers, see Matt Neuburg's
"Are Input Managers the Work of the Devil?" 2006-02-20.)
<http://www.ksuther.com/chax/>
<http://db.tidbits.com/article/8430>
Chax's feature list is as long as my arm, but here are the features
I find most useful.
**Tabbed Browsing** -- This is Chax's marquee feature, and the single
capability that makes it worthwhile for many people. Instead of
every chat appearing in its own window by default, Chax can embed
them all in one window, separating them with tabs that look and work
just like tabs in Safari. You can also "tear off" a tab to make it
into its own window, if you want to watch multiple chats
simultaneously. Tab names change color if the other user in that tab
is typing or if there's a new message you haven't yet seen, and the
tabs contain both names and user icons. You can move between tabs by
clicking or with keyboard shortcuts, and you can even set the edge
of the window that should contain the tabs (top and bottom are good
if you have relatively few active chats most of the time; left and
right are good if you have tons of active chats).
**Improved Away Handling** -- Although Chax can't implement my
suggestion of how iChat status should work, it does improve the
situation. You can set Chax to make your status Away after a
user-specified number of minutes, so if you're Available, then leave
your computer, iChat first changes your status to Idle, then Chax
later changes it to Away after the time you set elapses. In my case,
you probably wouldn't see Idle as my state very often, since Chax
can also switch the state to Away (with a custom message) when the
screen saver activates, as it does on my Mac after about 5 minutes.
I figure that if my screen saver is active, it's a good indication
that I really won't see any incoming messages. Plus, Chax can
automatically reply to incoming messages when you're away (once per
conversation), and you can set a custom reply.
**Better Notifications** -- iChat has a variety of alert sounds you
can set, but I find them annoying if I'm not actually sitting at the
Mac, so I like the fact that Chax can disable them if I'm Away or
Idle. If I really don't want to be interrupted audibly (such as when
I'm recording a podcast), I can turn them off when Available too. I
don't tend to think of the Dock as a place for changing information,
but Chax has a variety of options for showing notifications there.
More useful for me is its support for the universal Growl
notification system; I really like seeing the first message of new
chats appear briefly in a Growl notification that slides up from the
bottom of my screen no matter what application I'm currently using.
<http://growl.info/>
**Chat Enhancements** -- Chax also provides some tweaks to how chats
themselves work. You can set Chax to accept text chat invitations
and incoming file transfers automatically, though it warns you that
the latter is of course a security risk. It can warn you before you
send a message to a mobile phone user, enable you to open received
graphics in Preview with a double-click, and can require you to
confirm quitting when there are open message windows (it's always
embarrassing when you leave a chat because you thought you were
quitting a different application). Chax can also hide the smiley
button in the text input line and can embed a variety of status
changes along with the chats themselves, so you can keep track of
when people come and go. And lastly, it can disable
picture-in-picture in video chats, though I quite like that aspect
of iChat, and it can keep audio and video chats going during active
file transfers. If you're disconnected by a flaky Internet
connection, Chax can automatically try to reconnect you, and it
provides a variety of options for modifying the look and feel of
your chat and buddy list windows.
**Chax in the Box** -- Apple has promised numerous enhancements to
iChat for Leopard, but the kind of configuration flexibility that
Chax provides isn't usually the sort of thing Apple likes to inflict
on undemanding users. But for those of us who prefer to configure
our environments just so, Chax is an essential addition to iChat
now, and I suspect it will continue to be equally as relevant in
Leopard.
Chax 1.4.8 is a universal binary and requires at least Mac OS X
10.4.3 or later. It's a 1 MB download.
Stick 3 GB of RAM in an Intel Core 2 Duo iMac, MacBook
------------------------------------------------------
by Glenn Fleishman <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
article link: <http://db.tidbits.com/article/8917>
Other World Computing has a 3 GB memory kit that it says is a first
for Intel Core 2 Duo MacBook laptops. Apple doesn't offer this
option. The same $340 kit - a set of one 1 GB and one 2 GB PC5300
DDR2 SO-DIMM modules - also works with the Core 2 Duo iMac and the
15-inch, 2.16 GHz Core 2 Duo MacBook Pro. The other two standard
MacBook Pro models include 2 GB as two 1 GB modules, and can be
upgraded by swapping one of those modules for a 2 GB unit for $260
from Other World Computing.
<http://eshop.macsales.com/item/Other%20World%20Computing/53IM2DDR3GBK/>
Apple doesn't offer a 3 GB build-to-order configuration for either
its MacBook or iMac models, although the 1 GB stock MacBook Pro can
be upgraded to 3 GB for $750, while the 2 GB stock MacBook Pro
models can be upgraded to 3 GB for $575.
Other World Computing offers a trade-in rebate of between $44 and
$60 for 1 GB of memory, depending on the Mac model it was pulled out
of and the configuration (as two 512 MB modules or one 1 GB module).
<http://eshop.macsales.com/money-back-rebate/imacintel-memory#imac>
Apple recommends or requires pairing identically sized RAM modules
for all its Intel-based Macs. The Mac Pro and Xserve require paired
modules, but the company emphasizes the benefits for those models
that use system RAM for video operations instead of dedicated RAM
for graphics purposes - the Mac mini, MacBook, and iMac. The Intel
Core 2 Duo MacBook Pro models have no Apple recommendation for
paired memory; the original Intel Core Duo models did, just to add
to the confusion.
<http://developer.apple.com/documentation/HardwareDrivers/Conceptual/HWTech_RAM/Articles/RAM_implementation.html>
With paired memory, the processor can access RAM at up to twice the
speed of unpaired memory, which is especially important for video
output. What that means for actual performance can be determined
only through real-world benchmark testing.
It's possible that increasing memory to the maximum 3 GB may trump
the increased performance of paired memory, because additional RAM
can prevent an operating system from moving data back and forth
between RAM and hard disk-based swap files as it pages data and
program pieces in and out. The more RAM, to some extent, the less
time the computer spends performing relatively glacial hard disk
operations.
We recommend using TidBITS Contributing Editor Matt Neuburg's
freeware program MemoryStick to see whether or not you currently
rely on disk swapping enough that additional RAM might improve
overall application performance.
<http://www.tidbits.com/matt/>
Oddly, OWC's own benchmarking of a Core 2 Duo MacBook with varying
amounts of RAM and varying tests doesn't seem to show that more
memory produces substantially different results. However, the
benchmarks they used look at sets of operations or program
functions, rather than a typical Mac user's array of different
programs in real-world usage scenarios.
<http://eshop.macsales.com/Reviews/MacBook/Testing/Memory_Benchmarks>
Add a DJ to iTunes with SpotDJ
------------------------------
by Adam C. Engst <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
article link: <http://db.tidbits.com/article/8915>
"There goes the last DJ, who plays what he wants to play, who says
what he wants to say." -Tom Petty in "The Last DJ"
<http://phobos.apple.com/WebObjects/MZStore.woa/wa/viewAlbum?playlistId=161788&s=143441&i=161764>
I've never been sufficiently involved with radio to quite understand
Tom Petty's lament about the passing of the independent disc jockey
as "the last human voice." But even if I missed hearing Wolfman Jack
live in his prime, there are times when I'm listening to my favorite
music in iTunes or on my iPod that it feels, well, a little
repetitive. Sure, being able to play random selections from the
4,800 tracks in my iTunes library means I'm not listening to the
same songs over and over again, but in contrast to the days when I
listened to the radio, even my favorite songs can sometimes feel a
bit one-dimensional. The reason: no human voice introducing them, or
relating a bit of background at the end to give some depth and
background.
<http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wolfman_Jack>
Thanks to the Web-enabled SpotDJ, you can now add a panoply of human
voices to your existing music, whether you play it in iTunes or on
the iPod. SpotDJ comes from a tiny San Francisco company founded in
part by Scott Kleper, who made a name for himself in the Mac world
back in the late 1990s writing the KlepHacks shareware programs.
<http://www.spotdj.com/>
<http://www.printerport.com/klephacks/>
**Getting Spots Out** -- Once you sign up for a free account and
download the SpotDJ software (available for both Mac OS X and
Windows; nearly 40 percent of the users are Mac users), you simply
play songs in iTunes, just as you normally would. Whenever the
SpotDJ application detects that you're playing an artist or song for
which someone in the SpotDJ community has recorded a "spot" - a
short spoken piece - it waits until iTunes finishes playing the
song, pauses iTunes, and streams the audio spot, starting iTunes
again at the end of the spot. It's that simple.
An option on the SpotDJ Web site let you control how often spots
play, since hearing a human voice every so often is quite nice, but
having someone talk after every song could become annoying. For the
moment, SpotDJ is also restricted in how often it plays by whether
or not it has any matching spots for a particular song or artist.
The more esoteric your music, the less likely you are to hear spots.
You can also choose to hear spots in English, in the language you
record spots in if it's not English, or both.
Of course, not all spots are equally well done, so you can use the
SpotDJ application (which is essentially a Web interface in a custom
window) to rate the DJ from 1 to 5 stars, or add the DJ as a
favorite. Your ratings and favorites help control which spots you
hear; if you don't like a particular DJ's comments, rating them
poorly will ensure that you won't hear from them again (to quote
Lady Macbeth, "Out, damned spot! out, I say!"). You can also leave
text comments about particular spots; SpotDJ is new enough that I
haven't seen many comments yet, though I seldom watch the SpotDJ
interface while listening to music.
<http://www.tidbits.com/resources/2007-03/SpotDJ-interface.jpg>
Adding spots to your iPod requires a bit more work. Click the little
iPod tab at the top of SpotDJ's window, select a playlist, and click
Create Spotted Playlist. SpotDJ analyzes your playlist data, looks
for associated spots, downloads the spots (normally they're
streamed, but that won't work on the iPod, of course), and then
creates a new playlist that interleaves the songs and the spots
appropriately. After that it's merely a matter of syncing that
playlist to your iPod and making sure that you're not shuffling
songs.
**Getting Spots In** -- Of course, listening to spots is only half the
fun. The entire point of SpotDJ is that anyone can be a DJ and can
contribute spots about their favorite songs. When you find yourself
wanting to record a spot for the current song, just stop it, switch
to SpotDJ, and click the Spot This Song button. In the drawer that
appears, you can record your spot and preview it, repeating those
actions until it sounds the way you want. (Please use a decent
headset or microphone!) Then click Upload and your spot is
automatically uploaded for everyone else to listen to. Spots can be
specific to a song or can apply to anything by a particular artist.
Although it's easiest to record a spot directly in the SpotDJ
application, you can also record spots on the SpotDJ Web site, by
uploading a pre-recorded bit of audio, and even by calling the
company on the phone and leaving a message.
<http://www.spotdj.com/create>
<http://www.spotdj.com/upload>
<http://www.spotdj.com/call>
I don't have any particular recording experience, so I found that I
had to write my spots out first and then read them into the headset
mic, but after the first one, it was easy. I doubt my spots will be
heard all that often, since I attached them to specific songs that
probably aren't terribly popular right now, but you can listen to
them on my DJ page.
<http://www.spotdj.com/adamengst>
Once you've recorded spots, you can also use tools on the SpotDJ
site to email a notification to friends or to create an HTML snippet
for embedding a customized SpotDJ badge on your Web site.
**The Human Voice** -- Although SpotDJ isn't the most elegant
application around, it's simple to use and is sufficiently
unobtrusive that it's easy to leave running. I've been using it for
a few weeks now, and I quite enjoy hearing the spots.
The best ones I've heard so far are from Ben Fong-Torres, a fixture
in the music world who wrote for Rolling Stone and who has many
years of experience as a DJ. His many spots, apart from being
impeccably recorded, also often feature recorded interview clips
with famous musicians he was interviewing for Rolling Stone.
<http://www.spotdj.com/Fong-Torres>
Perhaps the most obvious use of SpotDJ is for artists to record
spots about their own songs - doing so both adds value and could
serve as a marketing tool because SpotDJ plays spots after 30-second
previews in iTunes as well. Other ways spots have been used is for
relating trivia, providing reviews, pointing listeners to related
music, offering interpretations of ambiguous lines, or just telling
stories about the music. I could even see SpotDJ being used for
music education classes.
Right now, SpotDJ has thousands, but not tens of thousands, of
spots, but that number only stands to grow as more people find
SpotDJ and realize how easy it is to record spots. It's a little
addictive, and great fun for anyone who is interested in sharing
opinions about music. And like the iPod, I think SpotDJ is one of
those services that somewhat transcends generations; aging hippies
can participate just as happily as young hipsters. We'll see...
SpotDJ is entirely free right now, and isn't currently doing much
with the usual approach of advertising and affiliate sales. In part,
I suspect that's because it makes more sense to license the
technology and content database to a larger player - can you say
"iTunes"? I'd certainly like to see Apple do so and build it into
iTunes and the iPod directly.
The more I think about SpotDJ, though, the more I think Scott and
the SpotDJ folks are on to something larger. It's bigger than music,
though music is a great start. What SpotDJ is enabling is ad hoc
audio commentary on arbitrary virtual objects. Podcasting may be all
the rage, but it's far harder to record a podcast than it is to
contribute a spot to SpotDJ, and podcasts stand alone, whereas
SpotDJ spots are linked to songs.
What if SpotDJ could play spots when you visited particular Web
pages, or viewed a particular book on Amazon.com? Most things on the
Internet don't have obvious end points, so you'd need a little more
control over when spots were played, but imagine loading a TidBITS
article and having a SpotDJ menubar icon display a "5" badge to
indicate that there were 5 comments about the article. Clicking the
menu would reveal them, in order of relevance, based on your
preferences and others' rankings, and you could play one or all of
them, while you continue to go about your business. It would all be
optional, of course, but it could provide an additional dimension to
our everyday browsing.
But that's all just possibility - for now, just check out what
SpotDJ can do for you in iTunes and on your iPod.
Apple TV: The Real Video iPod
-----------------------------
by Jeff Carlson <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
article link: <http://db.tidbits.com/article/8924>
Although the iPod has been "video-enabled" for more than a year,
Apple treats video playback on the portable device as an incidental
extra feature. The upcoming iPhone comes closest to the video iPod
that Apple fans have been waiting for, with its widescreen-capable
display. However, it turns out that Apple's true video iPod was
released last week - and it's the Apple TV.
<http://www.apple.com/ipod/>
<http://www.apple.com/iphone/>
<http://www.apple.com/appletv/>
No one will mistake the screen-less, silver box for an iPod, of
course, but in functionality - from the features to the menus - the
Apple TV is the iPod's wireless, tricked-out cousin. Rather than
build a box that would dominate your living room and take over your
television (as the Windows Media Center attempts to do), Apple
designed the Apple TV to be as familiar and easy to use as its
multi-million-selling portable media player.
The Apple TV started to become available last week after a
three-week delay from Apple's original shipping estimate. I received
mine on Friday, and although I've spent a fair amount of time doing
research from the couch, I'm not ready to write a full review.
Instead, I want to pass on my initial impressions, along with some
valuable pointers and sources of other great information that have
appeared online. For a rundown of the basic specs and capabilities,
see our article from Macworld Expo, "Apple TV Connects Macs and TVs"
(2007-01-15).
<http://db.tidbits.com/article/8812>
**The Good and the Bad** -- Bridging the chasm between the computer
and the television isn't trivial. The Mac mini was a solid first
step in the living room (and may be preferred by some people, as
I'll explain shortly), but it was still a computer attached to a
television. You interact with it like a computer, and the television
just happens to be a different variety of monitor. Apple's Front Row
software is helpful, certainly, but you have to switch out of
"computer mode" into "Front Row mode" to get close to the simple,
menu-driven method that most people use to operate their
televisions.
The Apple TV may be a Mac OS X computer at heart, but it operates
with a singular focus as a menu-driven gateway to your media. Its
interface is almost exactly like an iPod: a main screen containing
categories (movie, music, photos, settings) that lead to lists of
each item type, all listed as you would find them on an iPod. So,
the first main benefit of the Apple TV is that it will be familiar
to everyone who has used an iPod.
But the Apple TV needs to overcome some hurdles, so let's get them
out of the way first. It's not a TiVo that records broadcast
television; the only link with any type of TV feed would be if you
decide to stack the Apple TV on top of your TiVo or cable box. (I
don't recommend putting anything on top of the Apple TV: it runs
really hot!)
<http://www.tivo.com/>
It's also not a DVD player. Its content comes from other computers
on your home network (Mac or Windows), and only via iTunes. As a
result, the image quality of movies is, practically speaking,
limited to what Apple calls "near DVD quality": 640 by 480 pixels
using H.264 encoding. That's actually not terrible, but it is
noticeably worse than a DVD's output. For this reason, some people
may choose to go with a Mac mini or a stand-alone DVD player.
Another disadvantage is that the Apple TV supports Dolby Pro Logic
audio, not Dolby Digital 5.1 surround sound.
<http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dolby_Pro_Logic>
<http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dolby_Digital_5.1_Surround_Sound>
Of course, you can rip DVDs that you own using a program like
MediaFork (formerly known as HandBrake), MPEG Streamclip, or
VisualHub, import the movie files into iTunes, and then synchronize
or stream the video to the Apple TV. However, Apple's tagline of "If
it's on iTunes, it's on your widescreen" is a little misleading.
Although iTunes can play a variety of video formats, it won't
synchronize or stream material that isn't MPEG-4 video encoded with
H.264. If you ripped your DVD library into a different format,
you'll need to re-encode the movies.
<http://handbrake.m0k.org/?page_id=8>
<http://www.squared5.com/>
<http://www.techspansion.com/visualhub/>
The device does support 720p HD video, which is 1280 by 720 pixels,
but so far the only content at that resolution are HD movie trailers
and samples from Apple (the 720p option) or video you provide. If
you have an HD video camera and QuickTime Pro, you can export
footage from iMovie or QuickTime Player into Apple TV format. I'm
optimistic that Apple will provide HD movies from the iTunes Store
at some point, but even with compression, the file sizes for
feature-length movies would be large enough that it would take many
hours to download them over a typical home broadband Internet
connection. (A feature-length movie purchased from the iTunes Store
is about 1.5 GB, while HD content would be about 16 times larger
than that.)
<http://www.apple.com/quicktime/guide/hd/>
And although it includes built-in 802.11n wireless networking
(making it backwards-compatible with 802.11g and 802.11b networks;
see "AirPort Extreme 802.11n Throughput Limits," 2007-01-29), the
Apple TV can't download much content from the Internet, such as from
sites like YouTube. It will stream 30 second previews of selected
material from the iTunes Store (the day's top songs, movies, etc.),
but you need to purchase the songs or movies from within iTunes on a
computer. Direct purchasing and downloading is another feature that
I wouldn't be surprised to see in the future once Apple TV gains a
foothold in the market.
<http://db.tidbits.com/article/8834>
Lastly, it won't work on most televisions. You need, in Apple's
words, a "widescreen, enhanced-definition or high-definition TV
capable of 1080i, 720p, 576p, or 480p resolutions." Some
standard-definition TVs with component inputs will also work, as
Paul Kafasis at Rogue Amoeba discovered when his Apple TV arrived.
However, the display may appear scrunched; in a briefing last week,
Apple told me that the interface has been designed for widescreen
TVs, so hooking it up to a TV that falls outside the recommended
specs may not be ideal.
<http://www.apple.com/appletv/connect.html>
<http://www.rogueamoeba.com/utm/posts/Article/appleTV-2007-03-22-21-30>
So, that leaves us with a $300 device that plays media acquired
primarily through iTunes. It sounds like a crazy move on Apple's
part, but the widespread familiarity with the iPod, and by extension
people's familiarity with iTunes, makes the Apple TV more appealing
to people who see the value in accessing their digital content but
don't want to feel like they need to operate a computer (or need to
call on their tech-savvy friends) to do so.
The Apple TV benefits from Apple design, which comprises much more
than just the rounded-corner enclosure. Setup is easy and
straightforward, including the process of pairing with computers on
your network. As I mentioned earlier, the navigation system is
similar to the iPod. (However, as with the iPod, you still have to
get past the initial confusion of having a right-facing arrow icon
(actually a greater-than symbol, or ">") indicating more content,
but pressing the right-arrow button on the remote does nothing; you
need to press the Play/Pause/Select button instead. It's one of the
few odd design choices of the iPod system, but something that's easy
to adapt to.)
The interface's look is simple without appearing basic, polished
instead of garish. In fact, the Apple TV seems to value restraint;
the screen saver that appears after a couple of minutes, for
example, is composed of photos (or album artwork) that drift slowly
from the bottom of the screen to prevent burn-in on plasma displays.
Another nice touch: when you resume playing a video, the two options
(Resume Playing and Start from Beginning) are set against an
out-of-focus version of the frame you last viewed when you stopped
playback previously.
Lastly, the Apple TV feels like a product designed for the near
future. The U.S. changeover to digital television broadcasting in
February 2009 will bring more widespread use of HDTVs, which
continue to drop in price. Although you can't yet buy HD content
from the iTunes Store, it makes sense that Apple would offer it in
the future. And other capabilities, such as games like those found
on the iPod (or even special versions of normal Mac OS X games),
could be added by downloadable system updates. Perhaps the USB port
on the back could be utilized for more than just diagnostics, as
Apple currently states, perhaps even an adapter for a wireless game
controller like the Wii Remote.
<http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wii_Remote>
**Sync and Stream** -- Okay, enough speculation. When you first begin
using the Apple TV, you'll want to jump in and start watching your
movies and TV shows right away, but unfortunately there's a wait
involved.
The Apple TV synchronizes its content with one Mac or Windows PC
running iTunes; once you've defined the sync machine, media is
copied over the network and stored on the Apple TV's 40 GB hard
disk. That's a lot of data to copy, even on an 802.11n network.
Fortunately, you can also view content that's streamed over the
network and not stored on disk. If you start watching a movie on the
sync computer that hasn't been copied over, syncing gets put on hold
while the movie is streamed. When the show is over, or if you're
streaming audio only, syncing resumes.
To transfer your media more quickly at first, connect the device to
your computer via Ethernet instead of a wireless network.
<http://docs.info.apple.com/article.html?artnum=305254>
Only one computer can sync to the Apple TV, but you can stream to it
from up to five other computers.
**Remote Bleed** -- The Apple TV comes with an Apple Remote, the same
type that's included in all recent Macs. Out of the box, the
remote's infrared signal can work on any capable nearby Mac. My
wife's MacBook would jump into Front Row while I was using the Apple
TV.
To avoid this inconvenience, pair each remote to its respective Mac.
Hold the remote close to the IR receiver on the front and press and
hold the Menu and right-arrow buttons. After a few seconds, an image
of a remote with an interlocking chain link icon above it appears.
On the Apple TV, go to the Settings menu and then choose Pair
Remote.
<http://docs.info.apple.com/article.html?artnum=304991>
As more Apple Remotes invade our house (this is the third), I'm also
having trouble keeping them straight. My low-tech but effective
solution is to wrap a different colored rubber band around each one.
**Apple TV Hacks** -- Early Apple TV recipients wasted no time in
voiding their warranties. Within a couple of days, tinkerers had
disassembled the Apple TV, figured out how to replace the internal
40 GB hard disk with a larger one (which looks to be an involved
process), and configured the device to play other video formats such
as Xvid. In fact, it's amazing just how hackable this little unit
is. The Apple TV Hacks Web site is a good source for tracking new
developments, including ways to enable Remote Desktop on the Apple
TV.
<http://www.anandtech.com/mac/showdoc.aspx?i=2951&p=3>
<http://www.appletvhacks.net/2007/03/23/apple-tv-harddrive-upgrade-process/>
<http://forums.somethingawful.com/showthread.php?s=&threadid=2391956>
<http://appletvhacks.net/>
Still waiting for your Apple TV to arrive? You can get a taste of
the snazzy startup animation by watching a QuickTime movie.
<http://www.mcwiggin.com/AppleTVHacks/Intro.mov>
I don't have a burning desire to open up an Apple TV, so for the
time being I'm content to keep testing it from the couch. With
popcorn.
Hot Topics in TidBITS Talk/26-Mar-07
------------------------------------
by TidBITS Staff <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
article link: <http://db.tidbits.com/article/8925>
**How to rationalize duplicates across 11 drives** -- With thousands
of duplicated photos on 11 hard drives, where does one begin to cull
the dupes? (9 messages)
<http://emperor.tidbits.com/TidBITS/Talk/1182/>
**UK Mac ads** -- The UK versions of Apple's Get a Mac ads use two
actors who not only complement each other, but also bring a little
edge to the Mac/PC relationship. But is that good or bad? (7
messages)
<http://emperor.tidbits.com/TidBITS/Talk/1185/>
**We Are the Past** -- The TidBITS reader survey highlights some
differences in how age groups perceive each other, and how some
tools (like Web bookmarks) are adopted or ignored. (19 messages)
<http://emperor.tidbits.com/TidBITS/Talk/1186/>
**Automatically Attaching Network Drive** -- How can you make a
network volume appear automatically when the Mac is restarted? (6
message)
<http://emperor.tidbits.com/TidBITS/Talk/1187/>
**Macs in Science -- Feedback for Apple?** A reader is going to
provide feedback directly to Apple about Mac use in science fields.
(1 message)
<http://emperor.tidbits.com/TidBITS/Talk/1188/>
**Mail rule for empty (blank) Subject** -- In moving from Entourage to
Apple Mail, a reader hits a stumbling block in trying to filter out
messages with empty Subject lines. (4 messages)
<http://emperor.tidbits.com/TidBITS/Talk/1189/>
**Signed iWoz books for sale on Woz.org** -- Apple co-founder Steve
Wozniak is selling signed copies of his book. (1 message)
<http://emperor.tidbits.com/TidBITS/Talk/1194/>
$$
This is TidBITS, a free weekly technology newsletter providing timely
news, insightful analysis, and in-depth reviews to the Macintosh and
Internet communities. Feel free to forward to friends; better still,
please ask them to subscribe!
Non-profit, non-commercial publications and Web sites may reprint or
link to articles if full credit is given. Others please contact us. We
do not guarantee accuracy of articles. Caveat lector. Publication,
product, and company names may be registered trademarks of their
companies. TidBITS ISSN 1090-7017.
Copyright 2007 TidBITS: Reuse governed by Creative Commons license.
Contact us at: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
TidBITS Web site: <http://www.tidbits.com/>
License terms: <http://www.tidbits.com/terms/>
Full text search: <http://www.tidbits.com/search/>
Subscriptions: <http://www.tidbits.com/about/list.html>
Account help: <http://www.tidbits.com/about/account-help.html>
--
If you want to unsubscribe or change your address, use this link
http://emperor.tidbits.com/webx?unsub@@.3c557dc4!u=306a67f9
