Riz, Thanks for your work here
Some Quick points - Single file HTML button should be at the top, and possibly open to start with. This is where new users will be, lets not force a choice when they still do not know how to answer. - Personally I think at least download empty should always be visible above the choices as it will always be valid. However as argued elsewhere it would be better to use a Standard wiki with a little more than empty eg a few inclusions like contents, display the more page control, home close all and a little more. - I also believe once established a learn tiddlywiki and playground editions be pointed to here. If people can experience it without download/save of any other decisions I expect out adoption or conversion rate to go up. Regards TW Tones On Wednesday, June 24, 2020 at 2:40:44 PM UTC+10, Riz wrote: > > Hi, > > So I have uploaded the current draft of changes here: > https://ibnishak.github.io/TiddlyWiki5/ > > Apart from changed suggested by Eric, the text is practically same. Some > other major changes > > 1. The filters in Saver methods are done away with. As pointed out above, > most options appear whatever options you choose. Wherever options are > platform bound, it is mentioned clearly in the description. Otherwise it is > subdivided to meaningful categories keeping in mind "What average users > might want to see first". > 2. Text in "Installing Tiddlywiki with Node.JS" is slightly modified. > 3. Advice boxes CSS is updated. > 4. Wizard as discussed above. > > I have not updated individual savers. I have my doubts regarding a few - > HTA hack, Beaker, PHP saver. A few users in Reddit had complaints regarding > instructions about Noteself being outdated. Someone more knowledgeable > might want to look into these. Actual users of individual saver methods > could eventually update the docs with detailed instructions to set up > individual savers. > > Apart from general comments, I need specific feedback regarding the > following. > > 1. In the wizard intro, there need be a comment mentioning that only one > saver would work at a time. If you use GitHub saver, the local copy will > not be updated. This seems to be a frequent source of confusion. > 2. Right now in wizard the "Next" button appear only when next step > matters - like when user selects No or when there is a subquestion - like > which cloud service to use. Another option would be keeping the next button > appear always and urging user to click it on choosing an option. It might > involve animation- so could be costly wrt performance. > 3. How about changing all advice boxes (Tips, Warning, Preamble) in the > doc to the CSS given in the demo? Right now I have kept it limited to the > tiddlers I modified in this demo. > > Sincerely, > Riz > > -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "TiddlyWiki" group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to [email protected]. To view this discussion on the web visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/tiddlywiki/a3ddae07-ec34-46d4-b823-95d83f6a3669o%40googlegroups.com.
