On Mon, Jan 25, 2021 at 3:06 PM Odin wrote: > Hi Mohammed, >
Hi Odin, > > This is a great plugin! It looks pretty and feels intuitive when trying it > out on the demo page. I tried it out on a backup of my personal wiki that > contains schoolnotes. I copied the presenter macro from one of the demo's > and swapped out the tag for one that contains notes around a topic. Thank you. > My feedback: > > - The customizability is great. Being able to add a footer, adjust the > height and change themes is really cool. > > The presenter macro can be called with only one input parameter, the tag! so <<presenter myTalk>> fires up a presentation but It accepts many inputs to set height, width, theme, template, loop (non-stop going through slides),.... I tried to me a real citizen of Tiddlywiki and there is no need to learn anything special. > > - I think it is a great thing that the height accepts CSS inputs, I > set it to 90vh for a better full-screen experience. > > That's true. So, you can have a dynamic height and width when you switch from your monitor (small screen) to a projector on a wall (big screen). > > - With longer notes, the text will overflow and will not be visible. I > think it would be great to have it automatically adjust font-size to fit > the screen. Or have an option to adjust font size for some slides. (note, I > was testing it with tiddlers not made for slides ofcourse, but I can > imagine this is a handy feature If you want to be able to fit more text on > screen) > > I like this and was not successful by now. I welcome any help in this regard. BUT please note that a slide has four to seven items/lines. See the Best practice slideshow in demo. All in all, I think for slides we need tiddlers with little information. > > - Keyboard buttons work great. I like how there are several options to > move forward and backwards in the slideshow, and to enter and leave the > presentation. Took me a while to figure out the Q-key is used to leave. I > first thought it meant going into tiddler-edit mode. > > This is another issue. I should ask @BTC to see how to capture the reserved Esc key for exiting the presentation mode. Most browsers use Esc to exit from full screen and I could not set it for Tamasha. > - On the demo page the background slide behind the text when you > scroll past the toddler (in normal mode) creating a parallax-like effect. > Is this the intended behaviour? It doesn't impact fullscreen mode so it > isn't a problem in most cases. > > Yes, it is intentional, but I will move them to sub plugins and Tamasha will be shipped with minimum general purpose themes. > > - The slides are interactive, which is a great feature! I made slide > containing my recipe plugin dashboard and I could click on the tabs, > buttons, input text (but not remove the text with backspace clear the > input, delete worked). You could use this to hide text behind the details > macro from Shiraz, which is useful for presentations. I think this makes > Tamasha especially useful for making presentations about TiddlyWiki, as you > can show the wikitexts results and interact with them while in fullscreen > presentationmode. > > I will work on this, but yes the shortcuts used for navigation will not work for editing and like that! > > - (You could also for example add projectify to one of the slides to > create tasks while still being inside of the presentations. This could be > very handy) > > I tried projectify and Notebook but I did not edit in presentation mode! > > - I think a button that opens up the current slide as a tiddler and > then navigates you to it would be practical. For if you want to see the > original tiddler you can open it up right from the slideshow. > > This can be simply implemented! There are two templates! The vanilla template uses a setting to disable all links, duplicate it and enable links. Then it lets you go to the tiddler for edit! I can add a template and ship with Tamasha, but it is easy to create yourself. > > - When users create new slideshows, they have to tag each > slide/tiddler for each slide show. This can be a little tedious as it > requires you to open up each tiddler, edit it and save it again. Tinka > <https://tinkaplugin.github.io/>, the plugin package plugin has a > great way to select tiddlers to be packaged. You can search or use filters > to create a list that you then can select tiddlers from a checkbox. I think > something similar can be really useful to make the creation of slides more > seamless. > > This is what I thought about a lot. I tried to have a simple and semantic macro for presentation. It is quite simple to accept filters instead of Tags. See my dynamic table in Shiraz. but then there is more complexity for example to change the order of slides and so on... What I thought is, Commander lets you write a very complex filter to select tiddlers among many in your wiki and then with one or two clicks add such a tag. > These are my thoughts so far. I hope it helps you with the development. > Feel free to ignore the feedback if it doesn't fit your vision. I am really > looking forward to seeing how this project develops! I really appreciate your useful comments and I will absolutely will use feedbacks to improve Tamasha. > Op maandag 25 januari 2021 om 05:37:25 UTC+1 schreef Mohammad: > >> >> >> On Sun, Jan 24, 2021 at 11:35 PM clutterstack wrote: >> >>> Beautiful, Mohammad! >>> >> >> Thank you Chris. I will add documentation over the next weekend. >> Your feedback specially on the performance is highly welcome. >> >> Cheers >> Mohammad >> > -- > You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups > "TiddlyWiki" group. > To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an > email to tiddlywiki+unsubscr...@googlegroups.com. > To view this discussion on the web visit > https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/tiddlywiki/093cb70e-3516-4f22-8e47-b1eee3439fd3n%40googlegroups.com > <https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/tiddlywiki/093cb70e-3516-4f22-8e47-b1eee3439fd3n%40googlegroups.com?utm_medium=email&utm_source=footer> > . > -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "TiddlyWiki" group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to tiddlywiki+unsubscr...@googlegroups.com. To view this discussion on the web visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/tiddlywiki/CAAV1gMDSN8EKrCWK_To8Ackop1BTECha3UOc8RbQ5aFBsK7ibA%40mail.gmail.com.
