> And I agree with everything Måns said about "legobricks" :-)

Yep. Agree here too. Lego bricks are very important, and one of the things
that make TiddlyWiki really cool and such a joy to use.

I'd like to give my (personal) take on this though, in an attempt to explain
what's happening (and hopefully to allay your fears). (again, this is my
personal take)

The majority of coding is currently done (within Osmosoft) with TiddlySpace
in mind (and extensions to TiddlyWiki are applied when it seems appropriate
to do so), and in doing so, that brings with it a whole new set of concerns
that are simply not present in classic offline TiddlyWiki. The templating in
the list macro for example, is not an attempt to remove Lego bricks, rather,
it is an attempt to add in some new Lego bricks that you can play around
with, reuse, etc. The difference with these Lego bricks (as compared to fEt)
though, is that these new ones are hopefully easier to share securely within
TiddlySpace. That's not to say that fEt is a bad thing, rather that its more
suited to classic TiddlyWiki, where you're relatively free of attackers.

Similarly, the choice of wikitext over the standard HTML templating reflects
the fact that HTML is somewhat harder to sanitize than wikitext (whilst
wikitext still allows for a large amount of expressivity). That's not to say
its the right choice, rather that that's one of the factors involved in
making such a decision.

My (personal) hope is that the list templating will uncover some new and
really interestingly shaped Lego bricks that we haven't thought of yet, and
thus expand rather than shrink the amount available.

As to the point about wysiwyg, I can think of nothing more horrible. So I
wouldn't worry too much about that.

One final point about communication (that I've just thought of, I've
personally been expressing my thoughts on this sort of thing within
TiddlySpace itself, as they don't tend to get as cluttered as I imagine this
post is. For the most part, I've been doing this through experimentation
with new spaces (all of which are listed in my home space), and through
creating tiddlers in my home space directly (I tag the interesting ones with
"blog"). If you're interested, my space is at
http://bengillies.tiddlyspace.com (if you don't already know).

Thanks

Ben

-- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"TiddlyWiki" group.
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
[email protected].
For more options, visit this group at 
http://groups.google.com/group/tiddlywiki?hl=en.

Reply via email to