Thanks for the feedback, Dave. Kudos for Kosmaton again!

Off course, my setup for having a second display still would need a
ideal plugin, script or goto box, where after selecting a tiddler
(with all the sorting options: title, tag, date..) the tiddler also
shows in the expanded Sidebar (and not the regular Display area).

For this I'm testing a few imperfect options available at the moment:

1.) Personally would prefer a goto box which, after selecting a title,
displays the tiddler just below in the containing element. But
something like this doesn't seem to exist independently yet.

2.) The best available out of the box option would be
RecentChangesPlugin (which is used on Eric's Welcome page). It can
give a listbox with all tiddlers sorted by modified date and buttons
to either preview the selected tiddler just below, further to open it
in the regular display area both in view or directly in edit mode,
which is very useful too. It's clear disadvantage is that though this
usually works very well with recently edited tiddlers shown at the top
of the list, with too many tiddlers and having to find an older one
it's far from very practical.

3.) For the later use-case, and for making this 'sidebar 2nd display
area' feature more practical to readers too, FAQViewerPlugin (by Eric
too) comes closest. By providing a listbox with all tiddler
alphabetically sorted (if all tiddlers have been tagged with a dummy
tag and this tag used with the faqviewer macro), and even more
advantageous, the further option to narrow down the list of tiddlers
by tag or search. However for this use-case the plugin code has to be
modified because by default it only displays a 'Description' slice in
its listbox, and only falls back to the tiddler titles if no such
slice exists (which is easy enough even for javascript illiterate like
me, by simply replacing every occurrence of 'Description' with a slice
name that most likely doesn't exist). Two minor disadvantages for the
use of this plugin is that it displays 'prev' and 'next' buttons at
the bottom of the displayed tiddler and - which is much worse - jumps
there at the bottom if the sidebars size is too small for the whole
tiddler - which will be most of the time.

4.) So ideally, a plugin would be needed which would have the main
feature of TableOfContentsPlugin (by Eric again) to display a listbox
of all tiddlers with all common sorting/narrowing options, a search
box (as with FAQViewer), additionally being able to view the tiddler
in the element contained just below, and the option to open the
tiddler in view or edit mode (as with RecentChanges), and - more for
aesthetic reasons - preferable in a popup instead of a listbox. And to
top it off: a goto box as next to it.

5.) Still the best, of course, would be a completely new plugin which
simply creates two re-sizable display areas, with the feature to drag
and drop tiddlers between the two...

Though using a modified version of FAQViewerPlugin, which also allows
to display any tiddler at start by default, is already practical
enough. Simply using an common MainMenu (with lists, sliders, tabs,
treeview..) as tiddler displayed by default for readers - additionally
the RecentChanges panel for picking up the work where it has been left
for editors.


But maybe it would be a sensible request to have FAQViewerPlugin and
RecentChangesPlugin,combined - because their features overlap anyway,
and as they are now, have very limited use-cases each. Then all the
differing features of each could simply be combined to options
available in the macro itself.

Eric, if you happen to read this, what do you think?

-- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"TiddlyWiki" group.
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
[email protected].
For more options, visit this group at 
http://groups.google.com/group/tiddlywiki?hl=en.

Reply via email to