Hola Danielo - As a newbie I am liable to write something that makes others roll their eyes or think "we all know that". Despite that...
TWEdit is for mobile - right? I find it nearly useless TiddlyNotes - better except it doesn't work either As Noted - based upon TW engine, better user interface, and tiddlers are broken out into a ton of little files I am interested in an a similar application, personally. JWHoneycutt On Monday, September 26, 2016 at 12:51:47 PM UTC-4, Danielo Rodríguez wrote: > > Hello, > > This is both a reflection, a touch of attention and a desperate call to > all the users that feels like me, if there is any. > > Three years ago when I first discovered tiddlywiki I found both, > TWClassing and TW5. I decided to go for TW5 because it looked much better > on my mobile, and that gave me a feeling of future-proof software. As > opposed to TWClassic, which remind me to the first mobile web experiences: > an unreadable bird view of a page that required to zoom and scroll all the > time. So, as I said, despite it's lacks and faults I go for tw 5.0.5 > > After three years things haven't evolved for mobile users, or at least not > in the good way. The only community that grows is that one that doesn't > care about mobile, which is presumably the same that didn't care about it > on TWClassic before, but now on TW5. The only issues that are discussed and > the new features that are implemented doesn't care about mobile, it doesn't > matter, it is just take for granted, what we have is good enough. > > I read this forum mostly from mobile, and when someone makes an > announcement, or posts a link to any new good stuff my first impression is > the one that I have from my phone. If I'm unable to use it comfortably on > mobile I usually close that tab and forget about it. > > In a world that is moving to "mobile first, forget about desktop focus on > mobile, mobile rules!" experiences, tiddlywiki community is moving on the > opposite direction. Twitter, Facebook and Github are examples of how doing > things well: If I add their page to my home screen I can't distinguish it > from a native app. > > Just to mention some examples, Jed Carty > <http://inmysocks.tiddlyspot.com/> has a wiki that seems to hate mobile > screens, Mat's magic <http://twaddle.tiddlyspot.com/#TWaddle:TWaddle> > seems to be restricted to desktop browsers, Cardo <http://cardo.wiki> > requires so much horizontal scroll that I forget about what was at the left > side when I reach the other side of the wiki. I fought to death with Felix > to convince him to provide an alternative way of displaying Tiddlymap's > graphs, because on his extra-extra wide screen it was just fine to put > everything on the sidebar. A couple of alerts is enough to fill the > entire screen <https://github.com/Jermolene/TiddlyWiki5/issues/1743>, > popups are used everywhere like they were a good idea, and the new search > mechanism on a popup is just *a bad joke*. Most of the users here don't > see any advantage on using NoteSelf because syncing an entire file of > *6MB* on their high bandwidth internet connections is not even > noticeable. And those are just some random examples on an entire sea of > issues for mobile users. > > I would ask to those tiddlywiki wizards that do not want to care about > mobile to totally disable their creations on mobile, because the lack of a > feature is better than a bad experience using it. Github for example > doesn't have all the features on their mobile version. > > Does anybody subscribe to any of the things that I said above? Am I the > only interested on using tiddlywiki on my mobile phone? I want to know this > because it maybe it will be easier to leave tiddlywiki and go with any of > the products that cares about mobile than fighting the entire community. > > -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "TiddlyWiki" group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to [email protected]. To post to this group, send email to [email protected]. Visit this group at https://groups.google.com/group/tiddlywiki. To view this discussion on the web visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/tiddlywiki/a91bc062-e3b8-4d3e-9230-e77226b4b156%40googlegroups.com. For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.
