Hi Kelvin!

> In all the documentation for filters and lists, it always says "whatever
> matches first." This allows you incredible flexibility.

Yes, I know.

> You could choose to accept specifically whitelisted senders, and drop
> everything else under the sun - never confirm jack squat.

Did you read my complete article? Basically that's the way I do my
filtering (except for the '*@*' part, which seems a little strict for my
needs). The problem is as follows:

(1) I receive an email _from_ John Doe whose address matches a globally
    blacklisted domain _to_ a valid keyword address -> mail gets through
    (see my original article for the reason; I don't like to explain it
    all again ;)

(2) I reply to this mail and tmda is setup to put a dated address into
    the From: header. Fine.

(3) When John replies to that mail it is not sent to the keyword address
    he used in (1) but to the dated address tmda generated in (2). This
    dated address is not listed in any of the whitelist files, so John's
    address goes down through the incoming filter until it is compared
    to the addresses in the blacklist. Now here it matches the
    "*@johnsdomain.com" entry and the mail is dropped.

-- 
Ciao, Sebastian

* HP:    http://www.sauerland.de/~toyland/          PGP-Key available
_____________________________________________
tmda-users mailing list ([EMAIL PROTECTED])
http://tmda.net/lists/listinfo/tmda-users

Reply via email to