Amy, I was in the middle of reviewing the admin app when Remy called for the Tomcat 4.1.10 vote. I'll provide complete feedback when I have time to finish my review.
Regards, Glenn Amy Roh wrote: > Glenn Nielsen wrote: > >> Remy Maucherat wrote: >> >>> Glenn Nielsen wrote: >>> >>>> Remy Maucherat wrote: >>>> >>>>> I think milestone 4.1.10 is of good quality and we can consider >>>>> releasing it as the first stable release in the 4.1.x line. >>>>> >>>>> <ballot> >>>>> [ ] Alpha >>>>> [X] Beta >>>>> [ ] Stable >>>>> </ballot> >>>>> >>>>> If not voting stable, please suggest if possible a list of items >>>>> which should be addressed before a milestone can be released as >>>>> stable. >>>>> This vote will run until early friday, and the release announcement >>>>> will be made at that time if the release is rated "beta" or "stable". >>>>> >>>> >>>> I think the admin web application still needs more work. >>>> >>>> The list of attributes which can be modified for a Host is incomplete. >>>> The swallowOutput attribute has not been added. >>> > > I can add this to admin. You mean for a Context, right? > >>>> I have not been able to get DefaultContext config info to display in >>>> the admin webapp. >>> > > I've been hoping for someone to implement DefaultContext.remove() or > something like that so that the DefaultContext admin features are > complete. I raised the issue a while ago on the list. I haven't had > much time to work on the DefaultContext itself. Once the method is > added, I can add the DefaultContext config to the admin. > > >>> >>> >>> >>> Damn, we forgot to add that there :-( >>> >>> The admin webapp is not in my list of must-haves for a release >>> (except when it indicates there's a regression in Jasper). There's >>> also a problem with the number of people actually working on it >>> (except Amy, I don't see anyone else), so it may take a while to >>> polish it. >>> >> >> Then there should be something in the docs and release notes which >> state that >> the admin application is still considered alpha. >> >>> BTW, I don't see how adding support for your feature (swallowOutput) >>> qualifies as a showstopper ;-) It could probably wait for the next >>> milestone without affecting too many people IMHO. >>> >> >> That alone doesn't, but all of the other issues with the admin app does >> unless we note that the admin app is at an alpha release. Plus I found >> a number of places in the admin app code which states that things will >> be added later. > > > ?? > > What other work is missing in admin webapp other than DefaultContext? > It'll be more helpful if we have a list of things to work on admin to > make it complete. I haven't had much response/feedback from developers. > >> >> My vote will change to [X] Stable if the admin app is considered >> alpha, and documented as such. > > > I personally think it's beta but maybe I'm not aware of all the missing > features and other issues. Please let me know. > > Amy > >> >> >> >> -- >> To unsubscribe, e-mail: >> <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]> >> For additional commands, e-mail: >> <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]> >> > > > > > -- > To unsubscribe, e-mail: > <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > For additional commands, e-mail: > <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]> -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]> For additional commands, e-mail: <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
