-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA1 On 17/09/16 18:28, Aaron Johnson wrote: >>> Here's >>> >>> the same graph with more data, more request types, and of >>> course a lot more shininess: >>> >>> https://tor-metrics.shinyapps.io/webstats/ >>> <https://tor-metrics.shinyapps.io/webstats/>... >> If you feel that's interesting enough, would it be possible to >> also add the number of download of cryptographic signatures to >> the graph? >> >> I also would love to see a breakdown by operating systems if you >> consider it a reasonable thing to do. > > To these requests I would add a request for the methodology behind > releasing these stats. Are they raw numbers? Rounded? More > generally, how are the web logs sanitized? I’m interested in how > safe these statistics are to release and how they might be changed > to be even more privacy-preserving.
Good thinking! I summarized the methodology on the graph page as: The graph above is based on sanitized Tor web server logs [0]. These are a stripped-down version of Apache's "combined" log format without IP addresses, log times, HTTP parameters, referers, and user agent strings. [0] https://webstats.torproject.org/ I guess we'll write down the sanitizing process in more detail once we make this part of CollecTor, but that may take a few more weeks or even months. If you spot anything in the data that you think should be sanitized more thoroughly, please let us know! > Thanks, Aaron All the best, Karsten -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Comment: GPGTools - http://gpgtools.org iQEcBAEBAgAGBQJX37hFAAoJEC3ESO/4X7XBzP8IAJkHpRM7uVidFeGbI4iKgEf6 T/xuyeGJRx74YLL06SAy+pPnpMrfuu7VeSdUw/syjqpDsl33uql5RvyWRlDzZu8N 0IRtHeYtXY619FVTzNCm5jFXIpySBJ8xT95KDrMSX+NSZlEJahgILH5EEdkeXGNE TtOmococgysOx3rCA2EKTG5Y/OP7XSGuA9N1QfWm97KGwUpelv35eyP9Ydzfhi9I dEBEAZ9HkGn9E2VhCs9D9G4ANgwNQqcHlm8y+S85ZEdLMhf7Eu5LQHtR3Ic0K6f5 QPtT7RGx0rOUVeSm56vD2Y5gx9wZ/nNYO2V8zyyJB3crTKTj8/7pzKUEndf0C3A= =6FjO -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- _______________________________________________ tor-dev mailing list tor-dev@lists.torproject.org https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-dev