Thanks for the correction and update (from Ed Price), regarding uplink access directly via the cable modem (the cable company in my area does NOT support this condition). Similarly, Hughes offers a DSS internet downlink, but that also requires a phone link. Ed's comments directly support the existence of (some) competition to telco modems (versus the extended use of phone lines). On the basis that the cable decoder box must be tuned to the internet downlink, the cost, data rate, and sacrifice of access to OTHER cable channels while connected must be considered by the user/buyer. I often watch MSNBC business news on TV while connected to the internet for stock monitoring and trading. A mutually exclusive setup would not satisfy my personal needs.
For additional thoughts on this complex issue, many telcos are introducing various DSL (digital subscriber line) service for higher speed and bandwidth (and billing, which = profits). Most telcos have already beefed up their infrastructure at their routing and switching centers to handle orders of magnitude increases of calls using the same (in place) links they've had for years, plus simultaneous voice and data over the SAME home line. These changes have been paid for (by us, the consumers) via the government-regulated rates that assured the telcos made a reasonable profit. It may be true that telco profit margins have recently been reduced by the rapid growth of time- extended connections to the internet; however, these reductions are ultimately compensated by allowed rate increases (given the data confirms "less than reasonable" profits exist). I agree with Tony that government regulation is generally contrary (in the long run) with efficiency and cost to the users. However, once regulation is implemented/started, the removal of that regulation is tough and brings a new set of surprises. The telcos can simultaneously get more productive/efficient AND petition for a legislated price increase. That sounds like a WIN-WIN situation for the telcos to me. I wish my business had those options. Mike Conn
