I think your perception is very accurate. Everyone focuses on different things. People who have to have wifi don�t like that the Treo doesn�t. People who need a great camera don�t like the Treo, and so on.
Now I�ve been critical of the 650, but my concerns focus on things at the center of it being a smart phone: being able to store "enough" stuff, keeping time, being able to hear callers, not having it lock up in the middle of a call. Those are central to its function as a PDA and phone. It being a camera is really secondary, and that shows in the camera they chose to put in it. Even the 650�s camera isn�t great, but it�s usable now. Anybody who lives and dies by a great camera better not depend on the Treo for that - not yet, anyway. I have no doubt that the technology of digital cameras will continue to improve, and while the optics on a smartphone will probably never be great, the electronics in a few years will probably be very adequate. And yes, the updates, while a bit slower than I or others might want (why?), do seem to improve things. Cheers, Don ________________________________________ From: [email protected] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Wallach, Levi Sent: Monday, May 02, 2005 12:52 PM To: [email protected] Subject: RE: [Treo] Treo Lawsuit-- Buzzing-- May Have Merit! It always shocks me that some people have had many Treos which all have the same problem.� I had a Treo 600 for about 9 months without any issues so I wonder whether a) I'm just lucky, b) the people who mention these issues are 1 in 1000 but because they post about it and the 999 don't, it seems like there are more of them, or c) these folks have higher expectations than the rest of us.� Sage below alludes to the camera.� I used this occasionally, but never really expected that much out of it.� It did focus for the most part, but again, it wasn't a high priority for me.� The T600 I've really had no issues with, but I just wonder if I gave mine to one of these people would they find flaws that I just didn't notice?� As for the T650, the main problem (other than the memory issue which is being fixed), has been a lot of resets.� Part of this may be due to software conflicting with other software, but then again, I had pretty similar software on my T600 and never had issues with resetting...� Hopefully the update will make things a bit more stable.� Those who have downloaded the Sprint update, or the leaked GSM one, has your Treo been more stable? Levi Wallach Blog: twelveblackcodemonkeys.com DVD Review Site: dvdmon.com Pictures at: http://wallachexpressions.smugmug.com/Photos%20by%20Levi From: Sage Sokol-Lanting Sent: Mon 5/2/05 2:24 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Re: [Treo] Treo Lawsuit-- Buzzing-- May Have Merit! LOL....palmone's support is laughable. I paid 500$ worth of my hard earned money for a t600 last july, and have since had 8 (yeah, EIGHT) shoddy replacements. I want a refund, so I can spend my money on a t650 which fixes most of the problems which I had (for god sakes, the company shouldnt prototype the product on the poor customers) problem� is I dont have a choice in the matter, they just get to keep sending me shXtty replacements. my 5th or so replacement had a good camera, which means it functioned as a camera should, and would focus. 3 attempted replacements later, i gave up and kept one with a shitty camera. if they even gave me a HALF refund, 250$, i would be satisfied. At this point, I cant even get that much for my tmobile600 on ebay. Or even a customer loyalty discount for trading in a t600 for a t650, since the t600 was such a POS. Im fed up, as i've never had this broad a scope and numerous problems with a tech product before. -sage � ----- Original Message ----- � From: Craig Froehle � To: [email protected] � Sent: Monday, May 02, 2005 7:21 AM � Subject: Re: [Treo] Treo Lawsuit-- Buzzing-- May Have Merit! � So your car's water pump breaks at 40K miles and is replaced under � warranty.� That new part has a 12-month, 12K mile warranty, but it, � too, fails after 20K miles.� Do you really think the car company � should give you your money back after you've used the car for 60K � miles? � Same for the PDA -- you used it beyond the warranty period, so the � company doesn't technically owe you anything more for free since you � bought the device knowing what the warranty is. � *Should* the company try to make everyone happy?� Not really, since it � can't possibly do that, and would go bankrupt trying to do so, so it � has to draw the line somewhere.� That "line" is the warranty. � If you, or others, feel that this isn't the level of customer support � you deserve, then vote with your feet and buy another company's � products -- there are several out there selling smartphones. � Unfortunately, PalmOne knows it's the only game in town right now for � Palm OS smartphones, so its motivation to placate users isn't as high � as if it had some competition. � It sucks to have something fail on you and be treated in a way you � feel is unfair -- I completely sympathize with your situation (I've � been there myself many times before). The most effective strategy is � *always* to make your point buy not buying from them again.� Suing � them only takes even *more* of their resources away from customer � service (making the situation worse) while not really giving much back � to the customers (the lawyers generally keep most of the settlement) � and it risks putting the company out of business (which reduces � competition and generally makes the whole industry worse off for firms � and customers).� Lawsuits are not the answer...period. � On 5/2/05, Jim McGowan <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: � > But its a wallet thing for the company too....you put out shoddy � > merchandise, sell to unsuspecting innocent customers at a very nice price � > and then not have to deal with the fact you sent out shoddy stuff in the � > first place!??� If not a lawsuit how about a full refund instead of a � > replacement - that would be fair. � > JmcGowan � > � > At 08:32 AM 5/2/2005, you wrote: � > � > >Providing sub-standard customer service for a device that is out of � > >warranty should certainly merit a customer no longer giving that firm � > >his business (if customer service is important to him), but suing the � > >company over it is just stupid.� If that isn't "frivolous," I don't � > >know what is. � > > � > >If you don't like a company's way of doing business and it's not � > >illegal, vote with your wallet -- if enough people think like you do, � > >that company will be forced to improve or face extinction.� That is � > >the true way capitalism works, not through stupid lawsuits. � > > � > > � > > � > >On 4/29/05, Kevin M. Maloney <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: � > > > My recent experience with PalmOne makes me believe that a lawsuit is � > > > warranted.� Not because of a product defect, but rather, because they are � > > > not being honest with customers. � > > > I had a 600 replaced under warranty because of buzzing.� The replacement � > > > worked fine for about 6 months, and then started buzzing.� It was out of � > > > warranty by that time, but I called PalmOne and explained the problem. I � > > > tried very hard to convince them to fix the problem, but they insisted that � > > > my only option was to pay them $179 for a refurbished unit that I could � > > swap � > > > with my buzzing unit.� I even argued that you can find 600s on ebay for � > > less � > > > than that, but they wouldn't change the price. � > > > � > > > There was no way that I was going to pay PalmOne for another 600 that would � > > > likely have the same problem, so I hunted down the cigarette wrapper fix � > > > procedure and tried it out.� It worked!� For the price of a stale pack of � > > > cigarettes and a special screwdriver ($8), my buzzing problems were fixed. � > > > I was, though, and remain, furious that Palm One hasn't at least suggested � > > > to non-warranty customers this fix.� Instead, they demand $179 for a � > > > replacement unit that likely has the same design defect.� Is that an honest � > > > and ethical business practice? � > > > � > > > Sincerely, � > > > � > > > Kevin M. Maloney � > > > [EMAIL PROTECTED] � > > > � > > > farhanmemon_2000 wrote: � > > > > The Law Offices of Stan S. Mallison in Lafayette, California, is � > > > � > > > The scum offices of.... :P � > > > � > > > Come ON! Class Action Suits should be for things that cause pain and � > > > suffering, � > > > loss of work and money and stuff like that. Not a bug here and there in a � > > > freaking techno-nerd gadget. � > > > � > > > I'm sorry, but that's frivolous, and is just another example of why this � > > > country � > > > is going to hell in a handbasket. � > > > � > > > What next? Sue palmOne for making the Treo 650 but not include WiFi? � > > > � > > > FEH! I say! FEH! � > > > � > > > -Greg � Yahoo! Groups Links <*> To visit your group on the web, go to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/treo/ <*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: [EMAIL PROTECTED] <*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to: http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
