Hello, Nico.

On Tue, 6 May 2008 08:48:17 +0200 you said:

> PS Curious to know why you consider moving away and where to ? But that's
> maybe for another thread ...

I've been using Palm since the IIIx was top-of-the-line.  I loved the
IIIx.  I also loved the succession of three or four Clies that followed
it, the Kyocera 7135 Palm powered smartphone that came next.  The
Treos, however...

My first Treo was a 650, I got it when I jumped from Verizon Wireless
to Cingular.  I went through three 650s within my first half-year with
Cingular because the thing was so unstable and their diagnosis was
"it's the hardware, we'll replace it" when it was actually the OS
itself.  I could finally stop setting my watch by its crashing after
the third system update.

When I upgraded to the 680, there were indeed a whole host of
improvements, most of them minor, that added up to a much better
device.  But still...

Problems I'm having include:

* The well-known "pauses" when trying to do stuff, and they seem to be
happening more often.  

* Volume through the earpiece, speakerphone or headset (wired or BT)
all suck and always have.  

* All told, I think I've missed 10% of calls on my Treo because it
simply never rang, yet I get a "missed call" alert from the Treo itself
(not the cellular company) which tells me that the Treo received the
call, it just never alerted me about it.  This happens regardless of
using built-in ringtones vs added-in tones, native tone management or
third party ringtone management.

* Battery management sucks, I'm getting what I can only hope is bad
charge readings rather than a failure to properly charge on multiple
batteries (I now have three, two Palm OEM and one Seidio extended
charge).

And it's basically a slow system.

With the aborted OS upgrade that was OS6, the Frankenstein's Monster of
grafting features onto an OS that wasn't designed to handle them that
we have now, the continual delays in the next gen of PalmOS FOR Palm
devices from both Palm, Inc, and The Company Formerly Known As Palm
(Access), increasingly minor changes to the devices as Palm runs to
stand still, leave me with very little faith left in the future of a
PDA/Smartphone platform I used to love.  I am becoming increasingly
dissatisfied with it, I see no real improvements for it anytime in the
foreseeable future, so it's time to move on when I find something to
move on to.

Last week, I tried out an AT&T Tilt (those in other parts of the world
might now it as the HTC TyTN II or HTC Kaiser).  While the Tilt is a 3G
device, I'm living in a 2.5G area (EDGE is as fast as it goes here).
Even on the EDGE network, the Tilt does data almost twice as fast as my
Treo.  Using Google Maps as a reference, while the Treo is still
"looking up the location" with the server, the Tilt has already
download a complete screen's worth of map data, and when panning
around, the new map tiles are retrieved fast enough that it's almost
seamless compared to the Treo's having to wait, and wait, and wait.

Also, now that I've had a taste of WiFi, I want it.

I returned the Tilt only because as it happens, I couldn't stand the UI
of WinMob, even with HTC's additions.  The "couple of months" I
mentioned is because that's when the next gen of the iPhone and its
third party software are due, sometime in June or July.

-- 
Jeffrey Kaplan                                         www.gordol.org
The from userid is killfiled             Send personal mail to gordol

"The accumulation of all powers, legislative, executive, and judiciary,
in the same hands, whether of one, a few, or many, may justly be
pronounced the very definition of tyranny." - James Madison, The
Federalist Papers

Reply via email to