Counter-example: http://twitter.com/breakingnewson
posts way more than 20 times a day, posts no (or very few) links, and has 31k+ followers. I actually don't see this use-case (for the newspaper obits, etc) as being contrary to the purpose of twitter. Local news is turning into a big deal, and I think non-technical people are more apt to use and learn twitter for its simplicity than to learn how to use an RSS reader (my experience, anyway). Everybody uses (read: interacts with) twitter differently, and for different reasons. I have no idea what this "follow cost" is... who decides how many tweets per day is too many, anyway? 20 seems pretty low to me, actually. I say go for it, if you have the time/resources/desire... even if you don't get a ton of followers (which isn't the point either, and the topic for another time/thread), it will be a good exercise in learning how to interact with multiple technologies. -Chad On Tue, Mar 10, 2009 at 1:15 PM, TjL <[email protected]> wrote: > > On Tue, Mar 10, 2009 at 11:37 AM, Clinton <[email protected]> wrote: >> >>> You're confusing Twitter with RSS. >>> >>> RSS is a way to "push" this type of information out to people. >>> >>> Twitter is the wrong tool. >> >> Well, is it? Yes, you're right, I AM thinking of using this like RSS, >> but is that necessarily wrong? > > If you ask just about anyone who uses Twitter a lot, they would tell > you yes, it is wrong. > > Google "twitter is not rss" (including the quotes) and read some of the > results. > > RSS is RSS. People who want RSS go to RSS. > > What's the advantage of Twitter? That people can get them via SMS? Not > at the rates you're talking about publishing. > > With the exception of "Breaking News" I don't see any sort of purpose > to duplicate what RSS provides via Twitter. > > > >> To put it in context, there are lots of people who read the day's >> obituaries (or other family announcements) in their daily newspaper. I >> could imagine these people being interested in receiving a list of new >> notices daily. > > Sounds like a perfect job for a daily email digest. I'd sign up for > one of those if my local paper provided it. > > I would not, however, sign up for their Twitter feed. > > Seriously, I'm not trying to be a PITA or smart-aleck. > > There's not enough info in 140 characters to tell me what I need to > know, so all you can do is post a name, age, and a link to your > website. > > You are probably not going to send any "Breaking News! Maybelle Lewis, > 90, died" updates. Once a day is plenty. > > I'd MUCH rather give you my email address and get the daily digest > where I can get the full obit (and you can stick some other marketing > information in the email if you'd like :-) > >> My previous number of 3,500 was the number of new notices across a >> whole site (which consists of many newspapers), but for individual >> newspapers, we're talking about anything between 0 and 100 per day- >> usually more like 20-30. That is manageable. > > FWIW I believe that 20-30 a day is going to rate you as a "nuclear follow > cost" > > http://www.followcost.com > > which I point to as further evidence that this is not how Twitter > users intend to use Twitter. > > >>> If you/they are determined to do this, then the best way to do it >>> ("least-worst") solution is to make it so that you are sending the >>> fewest number of status updates as possible which are as specific as >>> possible. >> >> Sure. In this context, that amounts to a tweet for each new notice >> that is published - any less and we'd just be sending stats: "20 new >> obituaries", which is meaningless to everybody. > > Yes, but > > "Obituaries for John Smith, Kelly Green, Joseph Smith, Al Jones, [and > so on] http://tr.im/0000" > > would be better than 10 separate posts > > > >> I'd welcome other ideas for how to incorporate twitter into the site, >> or pointers to useful implementations by other companies. > > How other companies are using Twitter might be a good thing to checkout. > > Look at http://twitter.com/zappos for example. > > They aren't link-blasting you with sale information or special promo > codes. It's an actual person typing in actual messages, making > connections with actual people. > > On the other side, there is http://twitter.com/cnn who has 34,561 > followers, but even they posting less than 20 times a day. And they're > CNN. > > Look at how Rachel Maddow is using it http://twitter.com/maddow > Pointers to her show but not JUST that. > > If there is an on-scene reporter who wants to take on an official > Twitter account, that'd be one thing, but if it's going to be > automated, I think it's missing the point. > > TjL >
