Twitter is opt-in. If you don't want certain kinds of content in your
friends timeline, you just don't follow a particular account. I don't
think we should get terribly dogmatic about how an account is used
(beyond things that violate TOS). In fact, the flexibility of Twitter
and its API is a big reason why it has such a large dev community, I'd
say.

I subscribe to a couple broadcast-only "news ticker" accounts, because
I like the content and prefer to have it in my friends timeline over
other delivery systems.

--
Ed Finkler
http://funkatron.com
Twitter:@funkatron
AIM: funka7ron
ICQ: 3922133
XMPP:[email protected]


On Mar 10, 1:15 pm, TjL <[email protected]> wrote:
> On Tue, Mar 10, 2009 at 11:37 AM, Clinton <[email protected]> wrote:
>
> >> You're confusing Twitter with RSS.
>
> >> RSS is a way to "push" this type of information out to people.
>
> >> Twitter is the wrong tool.
>
> > Well, is it? Yes, you're right, I AM thinking of using this like RSS,
> > but is that necessarily wrong?
>
> If you ask just about anyone who uses Twitter a lot, they would tell
> you yes, it is wrong.
>
> Google "twitter is not rss" (including the quotes) and read some of the 
> results.
>
> RSS is RSS. People who want RSS go to RSS.
>
> What's the advantage of Twitter? That people can get them via SMS? Not
> at the rates you're talking about publishing.
>
> With the exception of "Breaking News" I don't see any sort of purpose
> to duplicate what RSS provides via Twitter.
>
> > To put it in context, there are lots of people who read the day's
> > obituaries (or other family announcements) in their daily newspaper. I
> > could imagine these people being interested in receiving a list of new
> > notices daily.
>
> Sounds like a perfect job for a daily email digest. I'd sign up for
> one of those if my local paper provided it.
>
> I would not, however, sign up for their Twitter feed.
>
> Seriously, I'm not trying to be a PITA or smart-aleck.
>
> There's not enough info in 140 characters to tell me what I need to
> know, so all you can do is post a name, age, and a link to your
> website.
>
> You are probably not going to send any "Breaking News! Maybelle Lewis,
> 90, died" updates. Once a day is plenty.
>
> I'd MUCH rather give you my email address and get the daily digest
> where I can get the full obit (and you can stick some other marketing
> information in the email if you'd like :-)
>
> > My previous number of 3,500 was the number of new notices across a
> > whole site (which consists of many newspapers), but for individual
> > newspapers, we're talking about anything between 0 and 100 per day-
> > usually more like 20-30.  That is manageable.
>
> FWIW I believe that 20-30 a day is going to rate you as a "nuclear follow 
> cost"
>
> http://www.followcost.com
>
> which I point to as further evidence that this is not how Twitter
> users intend to use Twitter.
>
> >> If you/they are determined to do this, then the best way to do it
> >> ("least-worst") solution is to make it so that you are sending the
> >> fewest number of status updates as possible which are as specific as
> >> possible.
>
> > Sure. In this context, that amounts to a tweet for each new notice
> > that is published - any less and we'd just be sending stats: "20 new
> > obituaries", which is meaningless to everybody.
>
> Yes, but
>
> "Obituaries for John Smith, Kelly Green, Joseph Smith, Al Jones, [and
> so on]http://tr.im/0000";
>
> would be better than 10 separate posts
>
> > I'd welcome other ideas for how to incorporate twitter into the site,
> > or pointers to useful implementations by other companies.
>
> How other companies are using Twitter might be a good thing to checkout.
>
> Look athttp://twitter.com/zapposfor example.
>
> They aren't link-blasting you with sale information or special promo
> codes. It's an actual person typing in actual messages, making
> connections with actual people.
>
> On the other side, there ishttp://twitter.com/cnnwho has 34,561
> followers, but even they posting less than 20 times a day. And they're
> CNN.
>
> Look at how Rachel Maddow is using ithttp://twitter.com/maddow
> Pointers to her show but not JUST that.
>
> If there is an on-scene reporter who wants to take on an official
> Twitter account, that'd be one thing, but if it's going to be
> automated, I think it's missing the point.
>
> TjL

Reply via email to