Hello,

I would like to report a likely error in Europe/Sofia's 1996 data, found
while
verifying tzdb's Bulgarian history against primary legal sources, and to
flag a
related open question for 1983-1990. This is a preliminary report: we have
initiated formal archive requests to establish what clocks actually did, and
will follow up with documentary evidence either way.

## Autumn 1996

tzdb ends Bulgarian DST on 1996-10-27 (Europe/Sofia is on the shared E-Eur
rules for this period, with no Bulgaria-specific citation in the europe
file).
We can find no Bulgarian legal basis for an October end in 1996:

* The DST regime in force through 1996 was established by Council of
Ministers
  Decree No. 6 of 26 January 1979 (State Gazette / Държавен вестник No.
  12/1979), which provides for summer time "until 30 September" each year.

* A last-Sunday-of-October end appears in Bulgarian law for the first time
in
  Decree No. 94 of 13 March 1997 (State Gazette No. 24/1997). Its Article 2
  also fixes the autumn change at 04:00 local time. The full text is in the
  government's legal-information system PRIS (pris.government.bg). The
  decree's repeal clause enumerates the entire prior regime: Decree 6/1979
and
  item 12 of Directive (Разпореждане) No. 15 of 11 March 1980, the latter
  marked as never published.

* We find no 1996 act changing the end date. PRIS records Council of
Ministers
  acts since 1990 and contains none on clock time before the 1997 decree.

If the law was followed, summer time in Bulgaria ended in late September
1996,
and Europe/Sofia is one hour ahead of reality (+03 instead of +02) for
roughly
1996-09-29 through 1996-10-27. The report tzdb cites for Bulgaria (Plamen
Simenov via Steffen Thorsen, 1999-09-09) describes the 1997 decree's rules
and
does not address autumn 1996.

Since law and practice can differ, before proposing a patch we have
initiated:

- a request to the Bulgarian National Library for scans of five national
  dailies for 27-30 September and 25-28 October 1996 (the clock-change
notices
  published to the public);
- freedom-of-information requests to the Council of Ministers and the State
  Archives Agency for the unpublished Directive 15/1980 and all clock-time
  acts 1979-1997;
- inquiries with the Bulgarian Institute of Metrology and the BTA
news-agency
  archive.

We will report what the archives show, in either direction.

## Why this matters to us

We build astrological software, which makes a historical UTC offset an
input to a
computation rather than a display detail. The quantity most sensitive to it
is the
ascendant, the ecliptic degree rising at the given moment, which completes
a full
circuit every day.

Measured at Sofia's latitude (42.698 N) for 1 October 1996, sampled every
minute of
the day: a one-hour error in the offset moves the ascendant by between 11.6
and
27.1 degrees, and it lands in a different one of the twelve 30-degree
sectors in
exactly half of the minutes of that day. The 50% is not a coincidence; a
one-hour
arc averages 15 degrees against 30-degree sectors. So for a Bulgarian birth
between
29 September and 27 October 1996, a wrong offset does not produce a
slightly wrong
result. Half the time it produces a categorically different one, and there
is
nothing in the output to indicate which.

That is also why we are asking about 1983-1990, where the published record
looks
incomplete rather than wrong, and why we would rather see a documented gap
than a
confident value. The same sensitivity applies well outside our field:
anything that
reconstructs past local civil time from records inherits whatever the
database says
about a date nobody can re-observe.

We are not asking for a change that happens to suit us. If the archives
show that
clocks in practice followed the October date despite the decree, we will
report
that, with the same evidence and in the same detail.

## 1983-1990 transition times

For 1983-1990 tzdb has Sofia on C-Eur rules (02:00s/03:00d transitions),
apparently ex-Shanks and uncited; Bulgarian retrospective sources
consistently
describe midnight transitions for the whole 1979-1996 period, and tzdb
itself
moves Sofia to midnight rules (E-Eur) in 1991 with no documented reason. Our
archive requests cover all sixteen transition nights of 1983-1990 (the last
Sundays of March and September) in the national dailies of the period,
asking
specifically for the announced hour. If any list members have
contemporaneous
Bulgarian sources (newspapers, broadcast listings) for these transitions, we
would be glad to hear of them.

For completeness: the same review confirmed tzdb is correct on the 04:00
autumn hour for 1997-1998, the decree text matches tzdb exactly, against
several Bulgarian secondary sources that claim 03:00.

Best regards,
Ivan Petrov Ivanov
Sofia, Bulgaria

Reply via email to