Hi. I finally got the time to make a review of Daniel's edits. https://wiki.ubuntu.com/Artwork/BreatheIconSet/Submissions?action=AttachFile&do=get&target=Breathe-Edit_0.10.tar.gz
First, I gotta say that I think that they look better that the old ones. Overall, I really like the icons with orange or green, but no so much the ones with yellow or blue which I found too muted. The "actions" icons looks pretty good. I wouldn't make any change, except for the yellow or blue like I wrote before and for the envelope that it seems kind of dark to me. In the "applications" icons there are several icons that I don't like for different reason (perspective, lack of details, I don't like the metaphor): accessories-character-map, accessories-dictionary, fusion-icon, gdm, preferences-desktop-wallpaper and preferences-desktop-theme. Also, the utilities-system-monitor and utilities-terminal icons, although can be improved, I don't think that they look better without the reflection. help-about, help-browser y system-software-update look a little muted (again the blue color). I love preferences-desktop-screensaver. In the "categories" icons I don't notice much change but I'd say that the only thing that I don't like it's the color of applications-internet, preferences-system-network and system-help. In the "devices" icons I noticed that the displays has changed and I think that they look much better that what I did, although I think that with a little work could look even better. For the other sections I could say the same that I said before about the yellow and blue colors. Also I'm not sure about the folder (I have to use the set a little more). Well, I think that's all. Take notice that this it's only my opinion and, of course, I'm open to hear everyone else's. That being said, I must add that Daniel did a fantastic job reviewing the icons and improving most of them. Gracias, Daniel. Once we resolved what to do with this review, I will try to be back on track making new icons and reviewing my old ones to improve them and making them more consistent (colors, perspective, etc.). Sorry that this take me so long. Regards. -- Seba (AKA spg76) http://www.ubuntu-ar.org
-- ubuntu-art mailing list ubuntu-art@lists.ubuntu.com https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-art
