Chaffetz subpoenas FBI for full Clinton email probe file
By <http://www.politico.com/staff/josh-gerstein> JOSH GERSTEIN
<https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ef8SLnFhmuU> Congress Just Subpoenaed the
FBI on Live T.V.! Is This The End For ...
House Oversight Committee Chairman Jason Chaffetz publicly subpoenaed the
FBI's full case file in the Hillary Clinton email investigation Monday,
delivering the document demand to a senior FBI official during a contentious
hearing where Democrats accused Republicans of mounting a partisan attack on
Clinton's presidential campaign.
"It's 'trust, but verify' is how it works," Chaffetz told FBI acting
legislative affairs chief Jason Herring. "You don't get to decide what I get
to see. I get to see it all."
After Herring said he could not promise to deliver all the investigative
summariesknown as 302sin an unedited form, Chaffetz sent the subpoena down
from the dais to the witness table where the FBI official sat with
colleagues from six other agencies.
"I've signed this subpoena. We want all the 302s....and you are hereby
served," Chaffetz said.
The chairman also complained that the FBI was trying to decide for itself
what was relevant to the committee's probe.
"Thats the way a banana republic acts, not the way the United States of
America acts," he said. "I dont expect to have to issue a subpoena to see
Despite the drama at the hearing, the dispute is a nuanced one, with the
oversight committee now in possession of some of the interview summaries,
but objecting strongly to the deletion of "personally identifiable
information" from the FBI reports provided to the committee.
One of the senior Democrats on the panel, Rep. Carolyn Maloney of New York,
noted that the obstacle to Chaffetz seeing classified records related to the
probe is not the FBI but with the House Intelligence Committee not releasing
that information to the oversight panel chairman.
Maloney noted that Chaffetz has asked House Intelligence Chairman Devin
Nunes for access to the classified records, but no vote on that request has
been taken or scheduled.
"These documents are not being withheld from the chairman because of
anything these witnesses have done.They are being withheld by the Republican
chairman of the intelligence committee," Maloney said.
Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley voiced a similar
complaint Monday, saying his panelwhich has primary oversight
responsibility over the Justice Department and the FBIwas unable to access
even the unclassified information the FBI turned over to the Senate because
of restrictions the FBI placed on the records.
"The FBI is trying to have it both ways," Grassley said on the Senate floor.
"At the same time it talks about unprecedented transparency, its placing
unprecedented hurdles in the way of Congressional oversight of unclassified
law enforcement matters. It turned over documents, but with strings
Grassley said he's objected to the limits, complaining both to the FBI and
within the Senate. "The Senate should not allow its controls on classified
material to be manipulated to hide embarrassing material from public
scrutiny, even when that material is unclassified," the Judiciary Chairman
and Iowa Republican said.
During the House hearing's more substantive exchanges, Herring said FBI
Director James Comey was committed to giving Congress as much information as
could "responsibly" be released about the probe.
Herring also defended the deletion of personal information from reports
given to Congress, saying that releasing sensitive information from
witnesses could lead some people to refuse to cooperate with the FBI in the
"It is critical for us as FBI agents to obtain cooperation from members of
the public....Witnesses who speak with us need to have confidence that they
can talk to the FBI without the risk of undue exposure," the veteran FBI
agent said. "I wouldn't want there to be a chilling effect for other people
However, Rep. Trey Gowdy (R-S.C.) noted that 302s are routinely circulated
outside the FBI, including to the defense in criminal cases.
Referring to the panel's ranking Democrat, Rep. Elijah Cummings, Gowdy
thundered: "Mr. Cummings used to be a defense attorney. He got to see all
your 302s...Probation officers get to see all your 302s. Why can't
Herring replied that the panel had some of the documents and would be
getting more as they're processed under the Freedom of Information Act. "The
remainder of the 302s will come out through the FOIA process," he said.
That response seemed to anger Gowdy and GOP members of the committee.
"Since when did Congress have to go through FOIA to obtain 302s?" Gowdy
The FBI representative said he had reached out to Chaffetz's staff to
propose a compromise on the information about people in the records, but
even that effort drew heat from the panel, as Cummings objected that his
staff hadn't been consulted.
Democrats devoted much of their time at Monday's hearing to accusations that
the GOP was using the session to harangue Clinton for purely political
"We are not a law enforcement agency. We are not a trial agency," Rep.
Stephen Lynch (D-Mass.) said, charging that his GOP colleagues were looking
to second-guess FBI Director James Comey's conclusion that no charges should
be brought in the Clinton email probe.
"This is terrible....This is a miscarriage of justice," Lynch said. "This is
a sad day in the history of this committee. This is a sad, god-damned day."
Democrats also faulted Chaffetz for convening the hearing in public Monday,
when the witnesses were initially told they were being summoned to a closed,
"Not only is it unfair, it risks the inadvertent disclosure of classified
information," Cummings said, noting that the committee held another
"emergency" hearing on an aspect of the email issue Thursday and plans
another Tuesday. "As far as I can tell the only emergency that the election
is less than 2 months away....I guess this is what happens when you try to
schedule an attack against Hillary Clinton for every day of the week."
Chaffetz said the panel's rules require that the committee convene in public
before going into closed session. He also said the committee tried to gather
officials from various relevant agencies for a closed-door briefing last
week, but they did not show up.
During the public hearing, the chairman also defended his committee's
timing. He said the fact the series of hearings are being held now is
attributable to Clinton's decision to use a private email server to handle
classified information and to return her records to State nearly two years
after she left office.
"I didn't pick this timeline Hillary Clinton picked this timeline," Chaffetz
said. "I dont care about the election and what time this is. Were going to
keep going at this. It is far far too important."
After more than two hours of public back-and-forth Monday evening, the
committee adjourned after 8 p.m. with plans to gather in a secure space in
the House Visitor Center for a closed session.
However, a committee source said late Monday that the much-discussed closed
session was never convened, reportedly because the room had not been
properly swept for the classified exchange.
A spokeswoman for the oversight panel did not immediately respond to a
request for comment on what transpired with the planned closed session.
On the 49th Parallel
Thé Mulindwas Communication Group
"With Yoweri Museveni, Ssabassajja and Dr. Kiiza Besigye, Uganda is in
Kuungana Mulindwa Mawasiliano Kikundi
"Pamoja na Yoweri Museveni, Ssabassajja na Dk. Kiiza Besigye, Uganda ni
Ugandanet mailing list
UGANDANET is generously hosted by INFOCOM http://www.infocom.co.ug/
All Archives can be found at http://email@example.com/
The above comments and data are owned by whoever posted them (including
attachments if any). The List's Host is not responsible for them in any way.