Michael Everson wrote:

>> 2) I used only capital letters, since they mirror more closely the
>> legibility issues associated with Old Canaanite legibility.
>
> Invalidating your "test" because German Fraktur of that style was not
> typically set in all caps, and native Germans fluent in Fraktur would
> have had trouble reading it.

Which is what I was planning to say.  I would have added that Fraktur
typesetters in past centuries created "all-caps" words by capitalizing
only the first TWO letters of the word, such was the difficulty *anyone*
would have reading Fraktur in all caps as Dean Snyder displayed it.

So far, so good.  But then Dean responded:

> So, you are saying there are glyph streams in German Fraktur that
> fluent, native Germans would have trouble reading. Then, based on
> reasoning being applied to Phoenician, Fraktur (or at least Fraktur
> capitals) should be separately encoded.

This reply is so completely devoid of logic and reason that it's clear
to me that any counter-reply based on logic and reason will fall on deaf
ears.  I will not participate further in this thread, nor any of its
ancestors and descendants.  Have fun, guys.

-Doug Ewell
 Fullerton, California
 http://users.adelphia.net/~dewell/


Reply via email to