I also opened an jira CURATOR-330 on this.

From: Wang, Simon
Sent: Monday, May 23, 2016 5:14 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Connection lost handling when entering double barrier

Here is the problem I'm meeting:

Assuming 3 node ensemble, my application has 3 clients and each one runs on 
same zk node (Client 1, 2 and 3). They use double barrier for coordination.

Client 1 is entering the barrier and waiting for the other 2. Now the other 2 
nodes are down and then the ensemble gets crashed and the client 1 gets 
LostConnectionException from enter(). That's expected.

After while the other 2 nodes come back,  all clients need to retry operation 
and reenter the same barrier (It might become more complex if creating a new 
barrier). Here is the problem:

If the session for client 1 is still alive, Client 1 calling enter method will 
get NodeExistException as the ephemeral node corresponding to that session is 
not deleted yet.

I wonder in this case what should I do from application side? Or I'm thinking 
can we add a mechanism to reenter the barrier but skip creating child node for 
this client if that exists?

I would like to open a Jira for this if required.

Thanks,
Simon

Reply via email to