Hello Felix, I will share the script if we really need it later. I'm using just one thread and one or more iterations.
This is the result with 3 iterations: timeStamp,elapsed,label,responseCode,responseMessage,success,failureMessage,Latency,SampleCount,ErrorCount,Hostname,Connect 2021/05/26 21:49:58.014,1789,1_MFP_Homepage,200,"Number of samples in transaction : 9, number of failing samples : 0",true,,0,1,0,SPXMIW3825,1247 2021/05/26 21:50:00.012,8838,2_MFP_Login,200,"Number of samples in transaction : 13, number of failing samples : 0",true,,0,1,0,SPXMIW3825,0 2021/05/26 21:50:08.888,201,3_MFP_InfoOfferta,200,"Number of samples in transaction : 1, number of failing samples : 0",true,,0,1,0,SPXMIW3825,0 2021/05/26 21:50:09.094,297,4_MFP_InfoConto,200,"Number of samples in transaction : 2, number of failing samples : 0",true,,0,1,0,SPXMIW3825,0 2021/05/26 21:50:09.393,784,5_MFP_InfoConsumi,200,"Number of samples in transaction : 3, number of failing samples : 0",true,,0,1,0,SPXMIW3825,0 2021/05/26 21:50:10.181,4132,6_MFP_Logout,200,"Number of samples in transaction : 16, number of failing samples : 0",true,,0,1,0,SPXMIW3825,0 2021/05/26 21:50:14.331,429,1_MFP_Homepage,200,"Number of samples in transaction : 9, number of failing samples : 0",true,,0,1,0,SPXMIW3825,0 2021/05/26 21:50:14.767,6270,2_MFP_Login,200,"Number of samples in transaction : 13, number of failing samples : 0",true,,0,1,0,SPXMIW3825,0 2021/05/26 21:50:21.051,182,3_MFP_InfoOfferta,200,"Number of samples in transaction : 1, number of failing samples : 0",true,,0,1,0,SPXMIW3825,0 2021/05/26 21:50:21.235,1353,4_MFP_InfoConto,200,"Number of samples in transaction : 2, number of failing samples : 0",true,,0,1,0,SPXMIW3825,0 2021/05/26 21:50:22.593,619,5_MFP_InfoConsumi,200,"Number of samples in transaction : 3, number of failing samples : 0",true,,0,1,0,SPXMIW3825,0 2021/05/26 21:50:23.215,3483,6_MFP_Logout,200,"Number of samples in transaction : 16, number of failing samples : 0",true,,0,1,0,SPXMIW3825,0 2021/05/26 21:50:26.710,438,1_MFP_Homepage,200,"Number of samples in transaction : 9, number of failing samples : 0",true,,0,1,0,SPXMIW3825,0 2021/05/26 21:50:27.152,6397,2_MFP_Login,200,"Number of samples in transaction : 13, number of failing samples : 0",true,,0,1,0,SPXMIW3825,0 2021/05/26 21:50:33.558,194,3_MFP_InfoOfferta,200,"Number of samples in transaction : 1, number of failing samples : 0",true,,0,1,0,SPXMIW3825,0 2021/05/26 21:50:33.754,281,4_MFP_InfoConto,200,"Number of samples in transaction : 2, number of failing samples : 0",true,,0,1,0,SPXMIW3825,0 2021/05/26 21:50:34.038,549,5_MFP_InfoConsumi,200,"Number of samples in transaction : 3, number of failing samples : 0",true,,0,1,0,SPXMIW3825,0 2021/05/26 21:50:34.590,3719,6_MFP_Logout,200,"Number of samples in transaction : 16, number of failing samples : 0",true,,0,1,0,SPXMIW3825,0 As you can see, the 2_MFP_Login transaction starts with a time of 8.8 seconds, then goes down to 6.2-6.3 in the second and third iteration. I tried to switch the implementation from "Java" to "HttpClient4", maybe this helped a bit. Thanks Il giorno mer 26 mag 2021 alle ore 21:37 Felix Schumacher < felix.schumac...@internetallee.de> ha scritto: > > Am 26.05.21 um 21:17 schrieb Gabriele D'Antona: > > Hello Felix, > thanks for your answer. > > Unfortunately, I can't share the script because it contains private data > like passwords and URLs. > > Maybe you can obscure/anonymize/remove those? > > > My java version is 11.0.3 2019-04-16 LTS, the OS is Windows 10. > > Which version of JMeter? How may threads are you using, how many requests > per second are you trying to reach, how much network traffic do you expect? > > > I can share the jtl file with one iteration of the test. As you can see, > the second transaction (2_MFP_Login) takes almost 8 seconds, while on the > BSM it takes something like 3,5 seconds. > As I said, if I increment the number of iterations, I get better times on > the subsequent runs (6.5 seconds for that transaction), but still far from > BSM. > > The list tends to strip of attachements. It seems to have removed yours, > too. > > Can you describe the test elements, that you are using? What is inside the > transaction that takes eight seconds? > > Felix > > Thanks > > > Il giorno mer 26 mag 2021 alle ore 21:10 Felix Schumacher < > felix.schumac...@internetallee.de> ha scritto: > >> >> Am 26.05.21 um 21:00 schrieb Gabriele D'Antona: >> > Hello, >> > I'm a consultant working for a customer that wants to test JMeter as an >> > alternative to HP BSM (now owned by Microfocus). >> > >> > I registered one navigation that is (or at least shoudl be) identical to >> > the BSM one (same URLs, same methods, same parameters). When comparing >> the >> > results, even on single transactions, the times registered by JMeter >> are 2x >> > the BSM ones. I'm talking of simple HTTPs calls, nothing fancy. I'm also >> > launching the jmx project from the command line (no GUI). >> > >> > I noticed that, if I run the jmx project with 3 or 4 iterations, the >> first >> > iteration is 2x longer than the BSM one, the subsequent iterations are >> > faster, but still 1.5x if compared to BSM. >> > >> > I hope you can give me some suggestions on this problem. >> > >> > Also, is there a way to fill the resulting jtl file only with the last >> > transaction? This would help having lower response times. >> >> You are quite vague on how you are setting up the plan and what versions >> of Java, JMeter or OS you are using. >> >> Can you be more specific? Maybe give a real example? >> >> Felix >> >> > >> > Many thanks. >> > >> >> > --------------------------------------------------------------------- > To unsubscribe, e-mail: user-unsubscr...@jmeter.apache.org > For additional commands, e-mail: user-h...@jmeter.apache.org > >
