Am 26.07.2011 um 14:28 schrieb Dave Love: > Reuti <[email protected]> writes: > >> Am 25.07.2011 um 23:17 schrieb Mike Hanby: >> >>> This may be a bug, but testing the ~/.sge_request approach produced the >>> following results: >>> >>> * qsub job without the -M arg, email was delivered to the address specified >>> in ~/.sge_request >>> * qsub job with -M and two emails are sent, one to the qsub -M email, the >>> other to the one in ~/.sge_request >>> >>> Instead of overwriting the maillist, multiple -M's apparently append to the >>> current maillist. Bummer. >> >> A list of addresses is valid in principle. >> >> The man page of `qsub` states the same beginning "Defines or redefines" for >> -M as for -q, and for -q it was an issue of some time until it got fixed and >> replaced the given wc_queue_list. >> >> I would suggest to file an issue. > > I can fix it if it's clear it's the right thing to do, but it looks like > a more general issue with list-valued options, and a bit of a mess. > Only -q seems to be treated specially by qsub. Also other programs use > a different mechanism for processing the options, for some reason, with > -M explicitly handled differently. Any strong opinions?
Due to the fact that an administrator can nowadays add himself in a JSV, I think it's suitable to have the default behavior to replace the list completely. I can imagine, that it former it was a nice feature for an admin to add himself unconditionally and the user couldn't remove him. -- Reuti _______________________________________________ users mailing list [email protected] https://gridengine.org/mailman/listinfo/users
