Aah I didn't read long enough. I just read the subscribing to specific
partitions, managing your own offsets and the controlling the consumer's
position sections.

So a follow up question - when I am subscribing to specific partitions and
managing my own offsets and controlling the consumer's position what does
the consumer group do? Do I still have to specify it all the time?

Thanks,
Rajiv

On Tue, Oct 13, 2015 at 1:14 PM, Rajiv Kurian <ra...@signalfx.com> wrote:

> I was reading the documentation for the new Kafka consumer API at
> https://github.com/apache/kafka/blob/trunk/clients/src/main/java/org/apache/kafka/clients/consumer/KafkaConsumer.java
> and came across this:
>
> "Each Kafka consumer must specify a consumer group that it belongs to."
>
> Currently we use Kafka but WITHOUT the consumer group functionality since
> I do the partition distribution based on my own app logic. I also persist
> my own offsets in an external store.
> I also sometimes need to consume from the beginning of a partition or just
> some arbitrary offset. Currently I use the SimpleConsumer to do this. I
> just give it the topics and partitions I want to consume from and I
> maintain the partition -> broker mapping myself. I also maintain the offset
> myself and when I need to consume from the beginning of a partition I ask
> the broker for the earliest offset and start consuming from there.
>
> I am glad that the new consumer does the broker -> partition mapping
> itself and I can get rid of a lot of code if I transitioned to it. But
> given that the documentation suggests that I have to use the Consumer
> group, it doesn't seem that it will support the lower level features that I
> need. I do see the commitSync method which suggests that I am in control of
> the offset management and for my use case I could just never call it. Is
> there also a way for me to specify which partition to consume from exactly
> (in addition to the topic) and also from which offset?
>
> Thanks,
> Rajiv
>

Reply via email to