On 22 April 2014 01:18, Narayanan K <[email protected]> wrote: > Hi > > We have a default pom file with packaging "war" for our codebase. > > From the same code base we also want to generate a normal jar and a > fat jar with dependencies. > > Currently solution that has been implemented is another pom-jar.xml > file that has the packaging as jar and maven-assembly-plugin to > generate the jar with dependencies. We use mvn install -f pom-jar.xml. > > But we are in a situation where if any new dependency is added to > pom.xml, we need to add to pom-jar.xml as well as it is the same > codebase. > > To avoid this we thought of couple of solutions - > > 1. Add maven-jar-plugin and maven-assembly-plugin to the default pom > with packaging war - so it generates a war file, a normal jar file and > fat jar out of the same pom. So we can do away with the pom-jar.xml. > > Not sure if this is a good solution. We tried this, but this is > working well only in maven 3.0.4. The assembly plugin is not working > well with Maven 2 (which is in our build environment) while generating > the fat jar. > > 2. Have a parent pom and put all the dependencies and plugins in that > and have 2 child poms in the same codebase with different names > inherit from parent pom, one that has packaging of war that generates > war file and the other child pom has packaging jar with maven assembly > plugin to generate both normal and fat jar. And all new dependencies > need to be added only to parent pom. > > This solution will make us have 3 pom files in codebase, doesnt look > very elegant,
actually depends on your point of view. To me this is the more elegant solution as you clearly see the relationship between inputs (pom.xml) and outputs (artifacts, e.g. jars wars, etc) > but will solve our dependency management issues between > the 2 packaging. > > > Are these good solutions? Is there any other good solution available > for this scenario ? > > > Regards > Narayanan > > --------------------------------------------------------------------- > To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected] > For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected] > >
