Hi Harold, In a message dated 2010.05.10 03:49 -0500, Harold Fuchs wrote:
"Bottom posting" is placing your text below (at the bottom of) the text to which you are replying. "Top posting" is placing your text above (on top of) the text to which you are replying. There is a religious war about the sanctity of the one and the total ungodliness of the other. Please don't ask why. The "third way" is to intersperse your comments within the text, with each comment immediately below the text to which it relates.
FWIW: In the 1980s, when it was DARPAnet, it seems like I only ever saw your "third way" - but then it was an almost entirely technical community, and people were both comfortable with editing and task-oriented enough to appreciate the efficiency of responding directly on point. When it became the Internet, the user demographic changed, and with it some of the fastidiousness about communication etiquette, prompting explicit recommendations like those of RFC 1855 to "quote only relevant parts"; "Content of a follow-up post should exceed quoted content." Then Microsoft introduced Outlook, with default behavior of posting above a fully-quoted message, and top-posting soon became "normal"; as many users know, MS invented the Internet.
John --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected] For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected]
