Michael Adams wrote:

>> 
>> The plot thickens.
>> 
>> Thanks to a private correspondent who wrote to me after seeing this
>> message, I have found that if one uses the Data | Sort workflow, one
>> does get a pop up box asking which column I wish to sort on provided I
>> select the entire spreadsheet before doing that. The main toolbar
>> buttons do what I described in my first post.
>> 
>> I wish Calc could mimic the Excel behavior as described here
>> completely. What it currently does with the toolbar buttons is not
>> terribly useful for most people (at least offer that pop up box).
>> 
> 
> What do you get using teh toolbar buttons if you select the entire range
> to be sorted (not just one column).
> 

A sort on the first column selected (always A if one selects the entire
page). It does not ask which column to sort on.

In my case, the columns are :

Column A - names of materials
Columns B-D - physical properties of those materials (numbers)

A dictionary sort on column A is not very useful (at least not most of the
time). It should ask the user to disambiguate the sort request with a pop
up box, just like Data | Sort workflow does.

Further, if I select just one column, it should show some rudimentary
intelligence and at least offer to sort the entire table (I cannot imagine
a situation where a user has multiple adjacent columns in a spreadsheet
with the same / similar number of rows, and would want to sort just one
column and mess up the entire data set).


---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to