-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA256 Amit,
On 2/13/17 6:55 PM, Amit Pande wrote: > As I understand, the JIO/BIO connector support has been dropped in > Tomcat 8.5 +. Correct. > While I understand the need to push to the NIO based connectors, > just wondering whether the JIO connector support could have been > left as it in Tomcat 8.5 and beyond. No. > We had extended the BIO connector to have a custom implementation > and that is broken now once we move to latest Tomcat versions. You will have to figure something out. Why did you need to create your own connector? > We're evaluating refactoring our custom connector but would > appreciate if there are any suggestions to get the BIO > implementation going even in 8.5 and beyond so that our custom > connector's functionality isn't regressed. BIO is problematic because of many requirements for non-blocking behavior. It's easy to emulate blocking behavior (e.g. ServletRequest.getInputStream) based upon non-blocking building blocks (e.g. NIO connector) but next to impossible to emulate non-blocking behavior (websocket, comet, etc.) using blocking building blocks (BIO connector). Unfortunately, the reality is that a blocking I/O connector is no longer feasible for Tomcat. So... what does your custom connector do? Perhaps there's a better way to achieve your goal, or perhaps Tomcat's connectors could be re-factored to make it easier to customize something specific for you without having to re-write the whole connector. - -chris -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Comment: GPGTools - http://gpgtools.org Comment: Using GnuPG with Thunderbird - http://www.enigmail.net/ iQIcBAEBCAAGBQJYolY6AAoJEBzwKT+lPKRYpCEQALefIMml43cS3r254mGE/pFS +QWDnaPG2t96oXM8GExUWm6jGBCGarxt7FBxxku112DS8+5NzkmEmP8BdkAkOIeN 7p/1jiGhZ4Koz7ER4JUzAXbbSFmJBjOXWfxYPzecZHrBBdfndoBx2PWRe/Ew4LNY ujJLSwZWuUSlZu1CBzPT/UU0klthqRRsfHH8JrHe64Jm+qZuPIITjr0G15IYSEU3 SihVCFMmA//yQfRb8rNN9UCM8lYYtu4oYwiythPNt30wz0e5XzOemyX+f/MMlFyD yWrKlOI9x+g9OVoMNSYvsq+9EO/TTzTW6mWtW26rnHskEz0i/98QIVqg9XIRIvrM 3mPq6Ufuq6Aq75WIVtJcKUe4voDu9KSmOHb7AKsLPFrB6WbzDluSSWD3VpxM/q5R gluvGG9CcCIRl1ie1ljg3qO90ZPno38RuQl+vxKSsGlY5t/mSce1M4ffBgJdg/T7 GpKZ/+GYTUuDg/jE+9pav/yO2mx8Hj/Oo6TvGCACT4o+sRXtceORcq93c8npCT0L 4+jvS2aJT0Gud3jn2gZ9qZnXGdFWdq59LTnZ1/s6p9gGHglCtWBx9j3fMkS53y1y 41giiY9GXKuEzyHUlSaTT3rLucJCzcJWvHi/k1muqclUn5/Ht2NVHXoLmxVPxgzL K0bIRYJ9K2R/ou+6YPiV =zu1M -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: users-unsubscr...@tomcat.apache.org For additional commands, e-mail: users-h...@tomcat.apache.org
