In that case, we differ in how we use the word "measure" and no further
discussion will resolve that issue.

For anyone who wishes to look at a reference that describes the
distinction between direct and indirect measurements and between
observed and inferred quantities, I suggest the monograph
_Measurements_and_Errors:_Theory_and_Practice_ by Semyon Rabinovich
(translated by M.E. Alferieff), 279 pages. (American Institute of
Physics, New York, 1995.) Section 1.4 pertains.

Thankfully, we can make room on the list now for discussions of greater
general interest instead of niggling over nits. Let's go metricate
someone!

Jim

Gene Mechtly wrote:
> 
> On Tue, 10 Jul 2001, James R. Frysinger wrote:
> 
> > ... Mercury thermometers do indeed measure changes in volume of the
> > contained mercury.
> 
> Not true, Jim, if "measure" means "reads out in units of", or
> "is calibrated in units of" as Joe suggests and I endorse.
> 
> Your meaning of "measure" seems to be "uses the phenomenon of"  which is
> of *no interest* to almost all *user* of measuring devices, although of
> necessary importance to the designers and manufacturers of the devices.
> 
> Gene.

-- 
Metric Methods(SM)           "Don't be late to metricate!"
James R. Frysinger, CAMS     http://www.metricmethods.com/
10 Captiva Row               e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Charleston, SC 29407         phone/FAX:  843.225.6789

Reply via email to