> if only Chip, Tony, Tim, and a few other prolific "answerers"
> would adopt that as their own policy, to ignore TPers, that
> would probably take care of about 80% of possible replies.  :D

If it's a direct question regarding my reply, I tend to rejigger 
top-posting on the first instance (hey, copying into Vim makes it 
fairly easy) with a warning.  Subsequent TPing in the thread or 
TP replies to somebody else's posts tend to get ignored pretty 
regularly unless it's a particularly tantalizing topic.  Cocky 
repeat offenders that ignore warnings get unceremoniously 
plonked.  So far I've only had to plonk a handful of folks from 
the Vim ML.

As for HTML mail, I have Thunderbird (and Outlook at work) 
configured to only display plain-text, and I have a filter in 
place that flags mail over 9kb (most HTML mail) from unknown 
senders as junk.  If the offender's mail fails to include 
plain-text, it shows up as empty and I just delete it.  If they 
do bloat it out to include both a plain-text and an HTML version, 
it's liable to get dumped in my Junk folder where I may or may 
not notice/care.

> But if garish html emails, attachments, etc., were to be
> banned as part of official list policy (message-size
> considerations, readability issues[1], etc.), then anyone who
> would willfully ignore those guidelines might very well
> warrant banishment from the list.

This is one of those things that could be filtered fairly easily 
at the mailserver level -- if a post includes an text/html 
mime-type, simply drop the email or send a warning email to the 
poster that HTML is prohibited on the mailing list.

Catching top-posting is a little more complex, but filters can be 
created to do it.  It would certainly make John's life easier on 
the list. :)  (BTW, Thanks, John -- I appreciate your unrelenting 
reminders.  Don't let the nay-sayers get you down)

> [1]  Blind folx who use text-to-speech modules can have 
> garbage coming out of the speaker with html emails

most with whom I've corresponded on the blinux[*] mailing list 
tend to use a MUA that simply ignores, strips, or converts HTML 
emails so they don't have to hear/feel HTML markup in all its 
hideous glory.

-tim

[*]
Blind Linux Users mailing list -- where both interspersed posting 
and top posting are used frequently.  The one that disorients me 
most is the "*no* quoting" replies. :)





--~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~
You received this message from the "vim_use" maillist.
For more information, visit http://www.vim.org/maillist.php
-~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---

Reply via email to