Posted by David Bernstein:
Friends in High Places:

   A well known tactic in getting a good placement for a law review
   article is for the author to thank in the first footnote important
   friends and colleagues who read and commented on the piece. The
   message to student editors is, "you may know who I am, or anything
   about the subject matter, but this article must be important or these
   important people would not have bothered to read it." Thus, long lists
   of prominent scholars thanked in initial footnotes are rather common.
   I just noticed that one Professor as trumped her professional
   colleagues by thanking the Diety in her initial footnote: "I first
   give thanks to God for guiding me through to the completion of this
   Article." That's even better than Posner or Sunstein!

   (BTW, it should be obvious that I'm being facetious; I'm sure the
   author was sincerely thanking God. For that matter, law review authors
   thank their friends out of courtesy, not simply because it looks
   important).

_______________________________________________
Volokh mailing list
[email protected]
http://highsorcery.com/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/volokh

Reply via email to