At 02:33 PM 1/27/2005, Edmund "JohnnyCJohnny" Storms wrote:
Neither Jed nor I have any reason to keep his papers off the site, other than his lack of cooperation. We publish all papers that can be understood and are of value to the field. As anyone can see, our standards are rather low, but not absent. Swartz's papers fall well within this standard. However, some papers do not, hence Swartz's charge of censorship.
Ed Storms is being disingenuous. It is not clear why continues the misstatements with Rothwell, but they require a response.
First, The matter involves the TITLES of the papers delivered at ICCF-10.
The "files" discussed here are not the papers, but the NAMES of the papers and the names
which were removed.
Second, there has been much previous cooperation by many with him, and then disappointment with him and Rothwell,
even by Prof Hagelstein who put ICCF10 together and watched the continued games of Storms and Rothwell
about this (and other matters reportedly).
NOTA BENE: The censorship involves removing the three paper TITLES of lectures (and a poster with active
cold fusion demonstration lasting one week, given at ICCF-10.
Third, OTOH, it may be true that LENR CANR site has "rather low" standards as Dr. Storms admits, but that is
their choice. Rothwell and Storms obviously have some reason from censoring the field.
======================================================================
Of course, neither Swartz nor I, nor Jed, can prove our individual viewpoints. Consequently, readers, if it is important at all, will have to come to their own conclusions based on the past history of each of us. Therefore, this is the last comment I will make on the subject.
In fact, the viewpoint against Storms and Rothwell is proven, and widely proven,
including by a series of letters, and even by the previous and original list of papers given at ICCF10.
======================================================================
It is unfortunate that censorship, plagiarism, and 'science by politics' exist at all, but as Dr. Mallove once said,
"This is known as science by politics -- it is disgusting. Storms doesn't have leg to stand on and he knows it." - the late Dr. Eugene Mallove
Q.E.D.
Dr. Mitchell Swartz
