Jed Wrote:

> Nonsense. Some of my best friends are anthropologists.

So are mine.  They're the ones who told me about the Maya.
I've read "Coming of Age in Samoa" and it describes behavior
that the Samoans themselves were very upset about.  This
was not a language problem or a cultural disconnect, this
was deliberate misrepresentation.  I guess it depends on
whom you wish to believe, Mead or the Samoans themselves.

Whether you like Margaret Mead or not, the fact is the field
of anthropology seems to have a greater history of fraud
and wishful thinking than other fields of scientific 
endeavor.

I just worry that some of this sort of thinking has spilled
over into other disciplines.

And yes, I'm sure you're right.  I would probably tend to
interpret an alien culture through my own beliefs and
prejudices.  But don't you think somebody would catch me
at it if they were in the same field of study?

M.

_______________________________________________
Join Excite! - http://www.excite.com
The most personalized portal on the Web!

Reply via email to