At 10:02 pm 05/10/2005 -0400, Stephen wrote:
>
  <snip>
>
> Indeed, as I understand it, in the Middle Ages, the Catholic church did 
> not allow ordinary church members to read the bible directly, on the 
> grounds that it needed some interpretation to avoid misunderstanding it.


And a jolly good thing too.  8-)

After all - Look at the situation in secular terms. Secular governments do
not allow the great unwashed to experiment with high explosives since they
may not only destroy their own bodies but they are very likely to destroy
the bodies of their fellow citizens as well. I'm sure that all Vortexians
would agree that this restriction is a reasonable one.

Now if one believes that one has an immortal soul and that when one dies 
that soul is destined to go to heaven or to hell for all eternity, then 
it is perfectly reasonable to prevent the ignorant and uneducated from 
tinkering with the instruction book.

After all, as the Penny Catechism 
<http://www.proecclesia.com/penny%20catechism/>
puts it.

  ==================================================================
  7. Of which must you take more care, of your body or of your soul?

  I must take more care of my soul; for Christ has said, 'What does 
  it profit a man if he gains the whole world, and suffers the loss 
  of his own soul?' (Matt. 16:26)
  ==================================================================

Like Jed, one may not agree on the assumptions, existence of God, divinity of 
Christ, foundation of a teaching church with divine authority, etc. but I feel
sure that even Jed would agree, that given those assumptions, to restrict
the instructions on making the religious equivalent of nuclear explosives
to people intelligent and responsible, is perfectly reasonable.  

Cheers,

Frank Grimer



Reply via email to