Eric--

I was taught many years ago that the energy bands are determined by quantum 
mechanics of the semiconductor, a coherent system of particles with electrons 
occupying discrete energy levels in that system.  There is no electrical wave 
that spreads throughout the semiconductor.  It happens instantaneously, if a 
new electron enters the system—no delay.   

If someone has an experiment that can sheds lighti on this question, I would be 
interested,

Bob



From: Eric Walker 
Sent: Sunday, June 28, 2015 8:05 PM
To: [email protected] 
Subject: Re: [Vo]:Re: Single-catalyst water splitter from Stanford produces 
clean-burning hydrogen 24/7

On Sat, Jun 27, 2015 at 2:35 PM, Bob Cook <[email protected]> wrote:


  In my concept elements of a system—a QM system—are entangled and act 
coherently and instantaneously.  Any two systems whose elements couple in any 
way constitute a coherent, although weakly coupled system.  For example, 
introduction of an electron into a semiconductor instantaneously changes the  
energy level of every other electron in that semiconductor no matter their 
distance from the new electron just introduced.


This seems mistaken.  I would have expected there to be a wavefront for the 
propagation of the new Fermi level along the semiconductor at some speed up to 
the speed of light in a vacuum following upon the stimulation of an electron.  
Also, I believe a typical semiconductor system has so many electrons at so many 
energy levels that it is no longer useful to think of it as a quantum 
mechanical system -- hence the treatment of the band structure as a set of 
continuous ranges.  Is this understanding incorrect?

Eric

Reply via email to