Jed, my reaction when I read this analysis was not the same as yours.
I'm inclined to conclude that the SEC ignored the letter simply
because no one below the top officials wanted the risk of rocking the
boat. Most people simply do not want to do anything that will
jeopardize their personal career. Anyone lower than a top official
would be taking a serious risk by starting such an investigation. Of
course, you might ask why a top official did not start an
investigation? The answer is simple, most top officials in the Bush
administration on many occasions have shown that they were either part
of the scam or agreed with the approach. This agreement is frequently
explained by calling it ideology, which can also be viewed as
incompetence. Hopefully, we will gradually discover just how deep
this corruption went as the various investigations get underway.
As for cold fusion, my discussions with various people show the same
reluctance to buck the system, even when they know the effect is real.
They are being paid to do a particular job and cold fusion simply does
not fit the requirements. This is especially true now that the
financial system is in the process of collapsing. Even the government
has no room for such a novel idea, even when it has been shown to be
real. Consequently, I think we are fighting the wrong war. I think
we will win the war only after someone demonstrates the effect at a
level and with an understanding that can't be ignored.
Ed
On Feb 11, 2009, at 3:53 PM, Jed Rothwell wrote:
A letter was written 2005 by a financial expert who discovered the
Madoff scam, and tried to warn the SEC about it. A copy is here:
http://online.wsj.com/documents/Madoff_SECdocs_20081217.pdf
The question arises: Why did the SEC ignore this warning?
Since I am the proverbial man who has only a hammer and therefore
sees all problems as a nail, a second question arises: What (if
anything) does this have to do with cold fusion?
My guess is that the scam remained undiscovered so long
paradoxically because it was so gigantic and obvious. It must have
seemed too amazing to be true. Imagine a busy official at the SEC
gets the letter from the expert. He leafs through the first few
pages. It is written by a smart aleck anonymous person who declares
himself a world-class expert, and who accuses one of the most
important people on Wall Street of running a $50 billion scam. That
seems so unlikely that I suppose a lot of people would not bother to
read the letter carefully. They might glance at it, conclude that
the author must be a nutcase or a character assassin, and then toss
it out.
Another likely reaction would be: "If this were true we would have
heard about it years ago. You couldn't keep a thing like this
secret." That is what the Scientific American said when denying that
the Wright Brothers flew in Dayton Ohio in 1905. That is what
countless people say about cold fusion.
The argument goes: "The experts would easily uncover a scam like
this, yet they have not uncovered it or told anyone about it,
therefore it must not be true." Or, in the case of cold fusion: "The
experts could easily find and evaluate all these papers you claim
have been published, and they could probably replicate the
experiments. They have not done this, therefore it must not be
true." These arguments are wrong because:
1. Experts did, in fact, easily uncover the scam. The anonymous
expert uncovered the scam using several different sources of
information and methods of analysis.
2. They did tell people. As the anonymous author notes some bankers
would not deal with Madoff. It was common knowledge among them that
he was probably running a scam. Why they did not make this more
widely known or tell the SEC I cannot say. People often do
inexplicable things. They often act irresponsibly.
In the case of cold fusion:
1. Anyone can go to a university library to find and evaluate all
these papers (assuming you do not trust LENR-CANR.org). Many experts
have done this. Opponents such as the editor of Scientific American
steadfastly declare that no papers have been published, but it is a
matter of fact that they have been, and anyone can see the editor is
wrong.
2. Experts have replicated, and told others. Again, declaring that
they have not done so is an invalid argument, but people often make
irrational and invalid arguments, just as they often do inexplicable
things. As they say in Scotland, there's naught so queer as folks.
- Jed