Edmund Storms wrote: I'm inclined to conclude that the SEC ignored the letter simply because no > one below the top officials wanted the risk of rocking the boat. Most > people simply do not want to do anything that will jeopardize their personal > career.
I thought about this possibility, but I do not think it is likely. Anyone in the SEC who heard about Madoff, and believed the allegations were true (or probably true), would make some surefire predictions: 1. The truth must get out, and probably soon. No Ponzi scheme lasts long. 2. When the truth does come out, the matter will be investigated by high officials and the Congress. It is the biggest scam in history, after all! 3. Anyone at any level in the SEC who is found to have had knowledge of the event will be in dire trouble. At least he will lose his job; at worse he will end up in jail. In other words, the risk of not rocking the boat is far higher than the risk of rocking it. This is because the SEC is essentially a police force, and it is their job to report crimes of this nature. They would be in the same position as a local sheriff who covers for a drug dealer. If you or I look the other way and pretend the people next door are not drug dealers, we will not get into trouble because we are not charged with enforcing the law. But a sheriff or an SEC employee is an "officer" -- meaning someone who must report a crime, or become liable himself. (An SEC employee told me this, years ago.) An employee at a bank or some other institution dealing with Madoff might be better off not rocking the boat, but they are halfway between a private citizen and a police officer. A bank employee has a professional responsibility to report fiduciary crime, and will lose his job, his license to practice law, or other professional standing if it is shown that he had knowledge of this. Civil engineer Samuel Florman pointed out that professional licenses are effective at ensuring ethical behavior. From time to time he heard about a builder who tried to bribe a civil engineer to cut corners. The engineers would also respond, "if I do that, I'll lose my license and my livelihood." Most of them, in fact, turned in the builder to the authorities -- which was also their professional responsibility. They did not do this because they were morally upstanding people, but rather because they had worked for years to get their engineering degrees, they made a good living, and they had no other way to make a living, and they did not want to jeopardize it. In Japan the news often features some shyster engineer who approved roads that sag and have to be demolished or buildings that would fall in a small earthquake; or a food company executives who sell tons of contaminated food (the way the factory here in Georgia did). This is not because Japanese professionals are inherently less ethical than their American counterparts; it is because Japanese government agencies are notoriously lax and the shysters usually get away with it. In short, I am not arguing that some people like to rock the boat or SEC employees are a particularly fine, ethical, brave & upstanding group . . . But rather that their organization and rules are structured to come down like a ton of bricks on someone in the organization who covers up crimes. Perhaps the Bush admin. restructured the SEC and changed the rules to have it act mainly as a lap dog and apologist for Wall Street, but years ago that was not the case. The Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) is *not* structured to crack down on malfeasance and professional misconduct, and this was the institutional cause of the Three Mile Island (TMI) disaster. Two other plants with the same design as TMI experienced the same equipment failure, with a stuck valve and a faulty warning light. The problem could have been fixed easily, at a nominal cost. An NRC plant inspector engineer reported it NRC officials. At that point, the system failed. They told him to shut up and stop rocking the boat. After the "accident" (which would be more properly called "the inevitable event that was waiting to happen") the officials were given a cash reward and the engineer was given the frozen boot. Clearly, that is an organization designed to foster corruption, failure, and disaster. It was not *intended* to foster disaster, but it was *designed* to as an accidental side effect of its main purpose, which was to act as a lapdog for the nuclear power plant construction companies and power companies. Perhaps it was reformed subsequently, but that was the main purpose before TMI. Many institutions, corporations, armies and the like that self-destruct catastrophically are designed to fail, not because anyone wants them to fail, but as an accidental and unanticipated side effect of some other purpose -- often an unspoken or unsavory purpose. The British General Staff in WWI was designed to protect the prestige and prerogatives of the Generals, and as an accidental consequence it protected stupid, unimaginative, closed-minded, inhuman bunglers whose decisions killed millions of British soldiers for no reason and to no military advantage, nearly losing the war. (That is not only my opinion; Winston Churchill said so at the time.) - Jed

