Jones Beene wrote:

... and your agenda of minimalizing the importance of Mills' theory to LENR
is also known and not secret.

As the British would say, this is utter bullocks. I have NO OPINION about Mills' theory, or any theory. I do not understand theory, and I could not care less about it.

The only use I have for a theory is to improve the experiment and enhance the reaction. Any theory that does that is fine with me. It does not matter whether the theory is correct (actually reflecting what occurs in nature) or whether it is wrong (imaginary -- and it gets the right answer by coincidence).


Secrecy, if there is any which is applicable to the Piantelli paper, would
relate to the influence of another unknown party.

Any which what? Mills theory? I have no clue whether it applies or not, other than the obvious fact that this is an Ni - CF reaction. (Or an error in calorimetry.) As far as I know, there have been very few credible Ni excess heat experiments. I am aware of many failed attempts. The original Mills large-scale cells discussed at MIT in 1994 were impressive but crude at best. They were never independently replicated as far as I know. I recall several attempts but they all failed. Srinivasan worked for months at SRI doing the classic small-scale Mills experiment but he saw no clear results.

The only rigorous, independent Mills-style Ni light water replications that I know of are Mengoli (1998) and Montereali, and it was not a test for excess heat:

http://lenr-canr.org/acrobat/Monterealianovellifb.pdf

I don't know much about Noninski (1992) but I think the calorimetry was better than Mills.

Two or three replications are not enough to convince me. The only other ones I know about that have been cited, such as Bush & Eagleton, have no credibility with me, because they didn't deliver the goods. (Literally.)

Stringham delivered but it did not work, despite Mallove's best efforts and Stringham's whole-hearted cooperation. As far as I know, no one has ever independently made it work. Miley delivered a report showing what he considers excess heat which, to me, looks exactly like zero heat, based on similar curves in papers by Miles and others, and on what I have measured myself. You could draw the line to incept above zero but I wouldn't.


... and that is why the comment about confusing and conflating "disproof"
with "null results" was meant to be a general thing, not aimed at anyone
specifically, and why your name was not mentioned in the previous posting.

If I am not mistaken, you have probably said something very similar, perhaps
uncomfortably similar (and probably many times) - to past comments from
skeptics of cold-fusion, who were fond of saying in the nineties that null
results "disproved" the phenomenon.

You are mistaken. Greatly mistaken. When an independent experiment produces the same results as the target, using the same materials and instruments, and yet it is shown that the results are prosaic and not caused by anomalous excess heat, that is strong proof that the first author is wrong. That is not a null result: it is a negative. A null would be if you set up the same equipment, do the same thing, but you do not see the temperature rise that the original author claims is caused by excess heat.

That's the whole point of replication! It is fundamental to the scientific method. The skeptics are right about that. McKubre has done many careful replications of claims and observed the same temperature effects, and shown that they do not indicate excess heat. Mallove and I worked our butts off (and I paid a great deal of money) to demonstrate that several other claims were errors in calorimetry. The skeptics claim that some experiments have been tested, replicated and disproved, and I agree completely -- because I did it myself in a few cases. Just because skeptics say something that does not mean it is wrong. A stopped (analog) clock is right twice a day.

- Jed

Reply via email to