Jed Rothwell wrote,
JB : For instance in later papers using Ni (1997-99), gammas, tritium and neutrons were documented. Tritium is radioactive and extremely hard to rationalize away as mundane, when it is found. Are you saying that someone could replicate tritium- and then find a mundane explanation of it? . . . JR This has nothing to do with the calorimetry, which remains iffy at best. So What! .. it has EVERYTHING to do with the existence of nuclear reactions. You are missing the forest for the trees. And in a big way. Let's start with the name: LENR. This field is about nuclear reactions. Heat is secondary or even irrelevant. If you are an expert in calorimtery, then perhaps you desperately want LENR to be about heat - and you may expend every effort to make heat an important issue, so that you can demonstrate years of hard-earned expertise to others, but sorry, heat should not be a primary concern for credibility in LENR. By focusing on a technique that is almost never demonstrative of final success to the Skeptic, experimenters are missing the best chance at rock-solid and incontrovertible evidence of a nuclear reaction - which is the radioactivity. And at the same time making a gigantic PR blunder. In the end, the existence of nuclear reactions is all that matters for credibility to a physicist. An on-demand demonstration of transmutation, or radioactivity, or CR-39 tracks will give you that. Heat will always be "iffy" at best, and is simply a crutch when radioactivity cannot be documented. Over the years, we have been led to believe that heat can be engineered from any nuclear reaction, but never is heat proof of nuclear reactions, so it makes little sense to go at from that angle. Once we have established that nuclear reactions are happening reliably - as a given - then let the skeptic figure out how such a reaction "cannot supply" excess heat, if that is an issue for him! And let the billions which will be switched from Hot Fusion to LENR provide the way to engineer for the heat. First you need rock solid credibility. It really is as simple as this: Radioactivity = Credibility. Transmutation = Credibility. Excess Heat = Controversy Jones

