Funny Krivit did not mention the stated source of the post: EVworld ... and
the crux of this boils down to my interpretation of that interview, not a
rumor. EVworld is e-zine with more credibility than his own, and they
scooped him on this story big time - but apparently he is reluctant to take
them on, man-to-man, or admit he has outflanked over and over, of late. 

I suppose the discrepancy in actual detail that permits him to mislabel this
as "rumor" can be reduced to this: is NASA's work "only" a Ni-H experiment,
similar to Rossi's or a bona fide "replication"? That is a matter of
interpretation given this particular time frame, and the extreme publicity
Rossi gets in Europe. But mostly that Krivit has largely missed out on the
story of his lifetime and compounded the error with trying to prop up
Piantelli.

Perhaps it would have been best to call NASAs effort an "experiment which is
similar to the Mills/Thermacore/Focardi/Piantelli/Rossi line of experiments
using nickel nanomaterials and catalysts (which are possibly unique) and
somewhat 'like Rossi' but not identical" - but that characterization is a
bit burdensome for all concerned. Obviously Bushnell is not in direct
collaboration with Rossi. Should I have made that clear?

That Krivit perceives there to be some imaginary difference here, worthy of
putting it into print with deceptive intent (as to the source) and yet does
not want to challenge Moore directly - may get back to whatever is his
propriety interest: financial, emotional, or otherwise, with Lewis Larsen.
It goes far beyond quality or even average journalism, and that should be
obvious to all by now.

Krivit could be correct about Larsen, and LL may be holding aces in the race
to understand this phenomenon, but clearly Steve's involvement goes far
beyond good journalism. Too bad. Last year he looked like the emerging
spokesperson for the whole field (to me), a real star who could move it onto
a national stage, but recently he has faded to little more than an
afterthought having largely missed out on, shall I repeat: the story of a
lifetime. Sad.

Steve is a decent man at heart, and I can only hope that he is getting
something valuable in return for his overzealous promotional efforts towards
W&L, to balance the lack of respect from the rest of the LENR community -
which he has seemed to encourage - in the past year. Maybe he really does
know something deep and important about Larsen that everyone else has
missed?

Jones

-----Original Message-----
From: Harry Veeder 

http://blog.newenergytimes.com/2011/05/02/rumor-of-nasa-replication-attempt-
of-rossi-is-false/

Harry

<<attachment: winmail.dat>>

Reply via email to