I have often thought about similar topics. Chapter 7 of my book touches on
it, especially the roles of contingency and incumbency in biology and
technology (Gould's theme).

Some observations:

We do, in fact, reboot the world every century or so. We have to. Technology
does not last, and must be rebuilt and replaced, albeit not all from
scratch. Very few buildings or machines last longer than 200 years.

They mention the QWERTY keyboard. The advantages of other keyboards have
been exaggerated according to some authors. Keyboards are likely to be
replaced for most applications with voice input, so we will reboot that.

The talk about electric power generation and the advantages of distributed
generation. This is gradually coming into use.

They talk about decimal clocks. The French introduced them with the decimal
system, but later abandoned them. There are some advantages of the 60 second
minute and 60 minute hour. The second is a natural sequence for humans
because it is the average pulse. 60 is a wonderful number.

Older units such as inches and feet have many advantages that we sometimes
lose sight of. These units are convenient for people working without
precision instruments or modern tools. U.S. and Japanese carpenters use them
for this reason. The other day, a fellow cutting up a fallen tree at my
house measured the length of the tree in feet by walking along it placing
one foot just in front of another -- measuring it in feet. One yard is the
distance from your hand to your chest. The 12 inches in a foot is another
wonderful number, being divisible by 2, 3, 4 and 6.

As much as I favor change and innovation, I am also acutely aware that we do
not remember more than a fraction of what our ancestors knew. Most knowledge
is lost. Quoting myself:

The staff at the University of Manchester built a one-third scale working
replica of a 1712 Newcomen steam engine. They gained new respect for
Newcomen’s original genius. They wrote, "the true functions of the key
components were fully understood and their relationship to the operation of
the engine appreciated." (D. Cardwell)

Our ancestors often set things up for good reasons which we have forgotten.
If we abandon their technology or methods we will find out why they did
these things, often at our peril. This is a key principal of the
conservative outlook, and there is much to be said for it.


 Prudence, indeed, will dictate that Governments long established should not
be changed for light and transient causes; and accordingly all experience
hath shewn that mankind are more disposed to suffer, while evils are
sufferable than to right themselves by abolishing the forms to which they
are accustomed.

On the other hand, some customs continue for no good reason, because we
forgot or never know how they came about. See the modern parable of the leg
of lamb:

http://allisonreynolds.com/blog/me-anderings/the-leg-of-lamb-a-modern-parable/

- Jed

Reply via email to