Dear Joshua, OK, I see our modes of thinking are not compatible. I cannot conceive such experiments without measurements, I think the large container is a bad idea and anti-technical, and I believe far analogies are not good in real problem solving. But otherwise I have to thank you for inspiring me-and I hope that we will have opportunities to discuss other Ni-H LENR experiments.
Peter On Sun, Jun 5, 2011 at 5:48 PM, Joshua Cude <[email protected]> wrote: > > > On Sun, Jun 5, 2011 at 9:33 AM, Peter Gluck <[email protected]> wrote: > > >Joshua, > > > >based on our constructive discussions re > > testing the E-cat I have sent the sketch of a protiocol for this experiment > to Vortex.but you have not noticed it and have not commented it any way- > even not "I ma not interested more" Because I think such experiments are > important- here it is again. > > > I gave a pretty detailed description of the sort of think I think would be > persuasive -- equivalent to the Wright brothers' 1908 demonstration. > > > The problems I have with your protocol have already been mentioned: > > > 1 - it requires quantitative measurements of flow rate and temperature and > therefore trust in whoever makes them. If that's to be the case, then some > method of choosing the observers needs to be in the protocol. And that could > be difficult for reasons Lomax gave: serious skeptics would be unwilling to > waste time or risk disapproval in getting involved in something that may > turn out to be an obvious scam. > > > I think it's much better to heat a large container of water with no inlets > or outlets; 1000L seems like a reasonable amount. Hot tubs can be purchased > pretty cheaply. > > > 2 - I think the impact would be far more dramatic without any input, > regardless of how carefully it's measured. As I've said, this not only makes > the effect more obvious, but in practice, a device that needs input is just > a slightly improved heat pump. Not revolutionary at all. > > > -- Dr. Peter Gluck Cluj, Romania http://egooutpeters.blogspot.com
