Peter Gluck <[email protected]> wrote:
> Jed, it seems there was a point in the contract, that the E-cat should > work continuously for at least 48 hours- and it didn't. Ah. You refer to the Sept. 6 test done by "Quantum engineers and NASA, but which fails due to leakage." Yes, Rossi's prototype equipment often fails because of leakage or some unknown problem. Defkalion says their reactors are more reliable. > The heating of > n office with an E-cat for 2 years is fairy tales for adults. > Except that someone recently mailed me photos of the damn thing, with people I know standing around it, and test data. Plus Focardi and others say they saw it running several times. So it is not a fairly tale. Every indication is that it is true. As I said, I have never caught Rossi telling a lie about any engineering technical claim. No skeptic has caught him, either, as far as I know. All of their examples of lies are their own misunderstandings. He says things about theory and transmutation that may not be true, but I would not call those statements "lies." I think he does not know much about theory. Since I know nothing, I cannot judge. As I mentioned, I am trying to get permission to upload those photos. It might help smooth the way for me to do that if people here would tone down these rabid accusations of fraud, made without a shred of evidence. It poisons the atmosphere. Expressing doubts is fine, but out-and-out accusations and calls by certain unnamed people to have Rossi arrested and deported are . . . unhelpful. - Jed
