On Wed, Nov 23, 2011 at 1:11 PM, Joshua Cude <[email protected]> wrote: > >> The poster is >> convinced that Rossi is scamming and there is no level of proof that will be >> accepted otherwise.
I find that assertion annoying. Several others including, IIRC, Cude, and I have said under what criteria Rossi's claims would be credible and those criteria are both entirely reasonable and easy to fulfill. Nor, as some assert, would proper testing in any way risk revealing Rossi's secret. On the other hand, selling E-cats in batches of 50 or more as a "plant" certainly does risk his secrets. Rossi has now categorically refused *public* pleas from four strong supporters of LENR/cold fusion -- Josephson, Celani, McKubre and Rothwell to get independent testing and I am sure many others have asked him as well by personal communications. I don't recall anyone here saying categorically that Rossi is scamming. Can you quote such a statement from a regular participant in this email list? I think Rossi's critics say he's *acting* like a scammer and he most certainly is for reasons I have carefully outlined here before. M.Y.
