Akira Shirakawa <[email protected]> wrote:

>
> Here's an article from The Salt Lake Tribune:
>
> http://www.sltrib.com/sltrib/**news/54640856-78/fleischmann-**
> fusion-cold-pons.html.csp<http://www.sltrib.com/sltrib/news/54640856-78/fleischmann-fusion-cold-pons.html.csp>


Yikes. That one is depressing.

The article is depressing and so are the stupid comments below it.

Steve Krivit, bless his heart, apparently thinks . . . well I am not sure
WHAT he thinks. He wrote:

"Remember that the early discoverers of fission did not immediately
understand why certain materials were producing heat with apparently no
loss in mass."

We'll do our best to remember! Maybe he thinks:

They discovered special relativity before radioactivity.

It is possible to measure the lost mass from nuclear reactions. (Nope. Too
small to detect)

Energetic chemical reactions cause lost mass. (Huh? Chemical ash plus CO2
is, of course, heavier than the original mass of C, as chemists discovered
when they first inventoried the products of combustion. There is lost mass
from relativity. The same amount per joule as for nuclear reactions.)

- Jed

Reply via email to