> From: "Jed Rothwell" <[email protected]> > Sent: Monday, May 27, 2013 11:20:43 AM > > "Comments on the report 'Indication of anomalous heat energy > production in a reactor device containing hydrogen loaded nickel > powder' by Giuseppe Levi et al." > > > Peter Ekström, Department of Physics, Lund University > > http://nuclearphysics.nuclear.lu.se/lpe/files/62739576.pdf > > > This document stands as its own rebuttal.
In line 1 he makes a dig at Rossi's spelling "indipendent" : that's NOT in the paper. Yes, it was originally written in Italian and translated. So? He follows Motl in treating the outer cylinder as steel, not steel-ceramic-paint. Did we do the math on this? It was very clearly explained in the paper why they went for a lower COP in March. He's following Krivit (or MaryYugo, but they're the same person, aren't they?) on Levi/Rossi being "old buddies". There's no evidence that Levi met Rossi before the Dec 2010 test, and was introduced to him by Forcadi. etc etc
