I wrote:

>   Do you think these are all errors?
>>
>
> I wouldn't know. I suspect these examples are either imaginary or fully
> explicable, and they were gathered by someone who does not understand how
> instruments work.
>

I say that because it seems extremely unlikely to me that experts have
spent decades working with these instruments and yet they make mistakes as
obvious as the ones you describe. This resembles the notion that Martin
Fleischmann never heard of recombination.

Experts simply do not make the kind of idiotic errors you describe here. If
you think you have discovered such errors, I am certain you are mistaken
and you suffer from hubris. No amateur can page through the literature in a
short time -- as you claimed you have done -- to find that many obvious
mistakes. I suppose that list came from some misinformed amateur. I have
seen many similar lists regarding cold fusion in places like Wikipedia.

- Jed

Reply via email to