I should point out my comments are about Maxtor external FireWire drives specifically. I don't know how they've designed their bridge but they've had all sorts of problems.

Some of the newer, big Maxtor (BARE) drives have had good comments such as the SATA drives that Craig is using but BEWARE the 80 & 120 in the unit you mention. I've just had a look at the spec sheet for the one-touch backup drive and it is a real joke. It appears that pressing the button launches Retrospect Express which ships with the drive.

You get charged a premium price for pressing the button rather than your mouse.


Hi Cal

There are some really bad user reviews for these units.  I'd also be
very wary of Maxtor drives generally.

I'm currently using a pair of 250GB SATA Maxtor disks and I'm pretty
happy with them. My array of five Seagate SATA disks is going very
nicely in the server here, too. I had bad luck with Western Digital last
year (three drive deaths out of seven drives) but that was apparently
just one bad batch.

Keith Palmer
7 The Strand Bunbury 6230
Phone: 08 9791 5556  Fax: 08 9791 5900