Hi Massimo,

According to document, source code and test, currently IS_IN_SET
accepts a list OR A SET as its first parameter "theset", and an
optional list as labels. Actually, something is inconsistent here. How
can an order-less set works with an ordered label? It can't.

I am writing to suggest an improvement to IS_IN_SET, to better deal
with order-less set.

Let's say I have following field in model.py of a online survey
application:

# I like to group the order-less values and their labels in a dict
DO_YOU_LIKE_SUSHI = {
  'yes': 'Like it? I love it!',
  'no': 'Come on, Sushi sucks!',
  'unknown': 'What is Sushi?' }

# Currently I have to use it in this style. It is too verbose to
mention DO_YOU_LIKE_SUSHI three times.
SQLField('do_you_like_sushi','text',requires=IS_IN_SET
(DO_YOU_LIKE_SUSHI, DO_YOU_LIKE_SUSHI.values()))


# So I suggest this modification in __init__() of class IS_IN_SET, in
validators.py:
      if isinstance(theset,dict): # Iceberg's hack
        self.theset=theset
        self.labels=theset.values()
      else:
        self.theset = [str(item) for item in theset]
        self.labels = labels

# Then, I can rewrite the model in this style. Notice the use of
anonymous dict. I think it is clearer.
SQLField('do_you_like_sushi','text',requires=IS_IN_SET(
  {'yes': 'Like it? I love it!',
  'no': 'Come on, Sushi sucks!',
  'unknown': 'What is Sushi?' }
  ))

# In case you want to ask, why a hack inside validators.py is the only
way to do this? I tried to define a subclass of IS_IN_SET in my own
model.py, it almost works, but fails when a record is going to be
saved in session (due to some boring pickling problem of __builtin__
naming space issue).

Regards,
Iceberg
--~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"web2py Web Framework" group.
To post to this group, send email to [email protected]
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
[email protected]
For more options, visit this group at 
http://groups.google.com/group/web2py?hl=en
-~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---

Reply via email to