Also, although ordering the logos randomly by default is a good idea, it would also be helpful to allow the user to select ordering by most recently submitted (and possibly by number of votes). At this point, I have seen all the logos submitted so far, so when I check the site, I just want to see the most recent submissions, which is difficult with the logos ordered randomly (the random ordering is also a hassle when returning from viewing/submitting comments because it re-randomizes the list on each re-load).
Thanks. Anthony On Oct 17, 5:40 pm, Anthony <[email protected]> wrote: > So, what's happening with the voting method? As already discussed at > length, the one-vote-per-person method isn't a good idea with so many > entries (particularly with sets of similar logos). For example, #5 and > #17 are probably splitting votes. > > We really should implement one of the other suggested methods: > * Approval Voting (vote for as many logos as you want): Probably the > easiest to implement, and should handle the "clone" problem. (Still > need the ability to change one's vote(s)). > * Ratings: Though for this to work, either everyone has to rate every > logo, or for each voter, each un-rated logo has to be assigned the > lowest possible value (e.g., 1 star). > * Ranking: Preferably using the Schulze method for tallying. Probably > the most complex to implement. > > If we're not going to do any of the above, then at the very least, we > should go back to showing the _number_ of votes for each logo (no need > to show the names -- they should remain anonymous). That way, at least > we could see if we are splitting (and possibly wasting) our votes and > then shift our support to a logo we like that has a chance of winning. > > If we stick with the current voting method, with 50+ logos, we could > easily end up with a "winner" that gets the support of only a small > percentage of the voters. > > Also, is the voting deadline still Oct. 19? > > Thanks. > > Anthony > > On Oct 13, 5:17 pm, Bruno Rocha <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > > Martin Mulone made the logovote application. > > > I am hosting at my server > > > You can post logo ideas, and vote for you prefered logo. > > > Better if you made an transparent canvas .gif or .png maximum 250x70 > > > Maximum of 10 uploads per user, Just one vote per user. > > > Take a look:http://blouweb.com/logovote/- Hide quoted text - > > - Show quoted text -
