It seems to be a natural idea to save Web application state from an unload event handler. But is it guaranteed that client-side database API is still functional at this point? And if it is - can one queue up more statements and/or transactions from statement callbacks?

I see two options here:

1. Delay leaving the page indefinitely, until all outstanding database operations have completed.

2. Leave the page immediately, canceling all outstanding database operations.

Option #1 seems undesirable because it allows a malicious or poorly programmed website to hijack the browser. That's a pretty bad user experience -- one that the database API's asynchronous callbacks were specifically designed to avoid.

Option #2 is not ideal, but it's workable. A beforeunload event handler can detect unsaved changes and prompt the user to cancel the navigation and save. Once the save succeeds, the page can update its UI to indicate that navigation is OK.

So, I recommend option #2.

Geoff

On Feb 8, 2008, at 1:44 AM, Alexey Proskuryakov wrote:


There needs to be some limits put on this, as otherwise a script could continue to use resources indefinitely after a browser window is closed. But I do not see where it is specified, explicitly or implicitly.

- WBR, Alexey Proskuryakov


Reply via email to